DOI: 10.1002/adem.201300254
Design and Fabrication of Hollow Rigid Nanolattices via
Two-Photon Lithography**
By Lauren C. Montemayor, Lucas R. Meza and Julia R. Greer*
Ordered cellular solids like the octet-truss and kagome
lattices have been reported to have robust mechanical
properties, for example a combination of high strength and
fracture toughness.
[1,2]
The geometry of these structures
enables creating materials with not only improved mechanical
properties but also with low densities and high surface area to
volume ratios. The ability to de-couple these historically
coupled properties through architectural control in material
design has the potential to push the envelope of existing
materials in a variety of applications, from photovoltaic
devices to hierarchical structural materials to materials for
sustainable energy.
[3,4]
3-Dimensional structures, whose global deformation is
carried out by bending of the individual struts within the
structure, are often referred to as bending-dominated struc-
tures. Cellular solids whose overall deformation is carried out
by stretching or compression of lattice members during
loading are denoted as stretching-dominated structures.
Stochastic foams with either open or closed cells represent
an example of bending dominated structures whose compres-
sive yield strength, s
Y
, has been proven to scale with the
relative density, r, as s
Y
/ 0:3 r
3=2
s
YS
where s
YS
represents the
yield strength of the parent solid.
[3,5]
The stiffness of such
structures scales as E / r
2
E
S
, where E
S
represents the stiffness
of the parent solid. An example of a stretching-dominated
structure is an octet-truss lattice, shown in Figure 1c, whose
strength scales with the relative density as s
Y
/ 0:3 rs
YS
and
the stiffness scales as E / 0:3 rE
S
.
[3]
These scaling laws hold
only for isotropic structures, i.e., whose unit cell has the
anisotropy ratio, R ¼ 1, defined as width/height of a unit cell.
[5]
For isotropic geometries, stretching dominated structures have
higher stiffness and strength compared to bending-dominated
structures for a given relative density due to the linear
relationship between relative density and both strength and
stiffness. As a result, these types of ordered cellular solids are
capable of outperforming the current open-cell foams, such as
stochastic metallic foams.
The relationship between fracture toughness and relative
density for a 2-dimensional open-cell foam has the analytical
form of K
IC
/ s
Y
r
2
while that for a stretching dominated
structure is K
IC
/ s
Y
r.
[1]
In addition to strength, the stretching
dominated structures also outperform the open-cell foams in
terms of fracture toughness. Another example of an ordered
structure is the so-called 2-dimensional kagome lattice shown
in Figure 1b, which is a stretching periodic-bending dominated
structure. In 2-dimensions, the stacked triangular unit cell is a
stretching dominated structure but due to the tessellation
pattern, the resulting lattice has a mechanism for bending at
the nodes between unit cells. As a result, the overall lattice has
both stretching and bending mechanisms; hence it is called a
stretching periodic-bending structure. Its fracture toughness
has been reported to scale as K
IC
/ s
Y
r
1=2
, rendering the
kagome lattices to be tougher than the stretching and bending
dominated geometries for low relative densities.
[1]
The
higher fracture toughness offered by the kagome lattice in
2-dimensions, compared to other lattice geometries, make it is
reasonable to expect similar advantages in a 3-dimensional
kagome geometries. Evans et al.
[6]
have created a macro-scale
version of the 3-dimensional kagome lattice but the structure
was limited to a single unit cell in height. The 3-dimensional
kagome unit cell presented in this paper can be tessellated to
create lattices of multiple unit cells in height, thus providing a
platform to fully study the mechanical behavior of the kagome
lattice in 3-dimensions. If the high fracture toughness
properties of the 2-dimensional geometry extend to the
3-dimensional kagome lattice, it will allow for the creation
of nanostructured materials with the ability to inhibit crack
propagation and increase damage tolerance of a structure for a
given constituent material.
[1,2]
Ultra-lightweight small-scale hollow cellular structures
have been fabricated using photolithographic techniques.
[4,7–10]
In contrast to traditional photolithography techniques, which
typically produce 2-dimensional structures, Jacobsen et al.
[9]
created 3-dimensional structures by exposing a bulk volume
of photoresist to collimated ultra-violet (UV) light through
a mask. In their process, a 3D polymer waveguide was
formed during exposure as a result of the change in index of
refraction between the cured and uncured photoresist. The
3-dimensional geometry created by the polymer waveguide is
fully defined by the lithographic mask pattern and by the
[*] Prof. J. R. Greer, L. C. Montemayor, L. R. Meza
1200 E. California Blvd MC 309-81, Pasadena, CA 91125, USA
E-mail: jrgreer@caltech.edu
[**] The authors gratefully acknowledge the financial support from
the Dow-Resnick Innovation Fund at Caltech and from the
National Science Foundation through L.C.M.’s NSF Graduate
Research Fellowship and J.R.G’s grant (CMMI-1234364).
The authors acknowledge critical support and infrastructure
provided by the Kavli Nanoscience Institute at Caltech. The
authors would also like to thank Dongchan Jang for assistance in
TEM sample preparation and analysis.
184 wileyonlinelibrary.com © 2013 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim ADVANCED ENGINEERING MATERIALS 2014, 16, No. 2
COMMUNICATION