The Determination of Brønsted Acid Sites in Zeolite ERS-7 by Neutron and X-ray Powder
Diffraction
B. J. Campbell* and A. K. Cheetham
Materials Research Laboratory, UniVersity of California, Santa Barbara, California 93106
T. Vogt
Physics Department, BrookhaVen National Laboratory, Upton, New York 11973
L. Carluccio, W. O. Parker, Jr., C. Flego, and R. Millini
EniTecnologie S.p.A., Via F. Maritano 26, I-20097 San Donato Milanese, MI-Italy
ReceiVed: August 1, 2000; In Final Form: NoVember 20, 2000
The deuterated acid form of zeolite ERS-7 (Si/Al ) 8.4) has been prepared by repeated cycles of D
2
O exposure
and calcination.
27
Al NMR data show that the relative proportions of tetrahedral and octahedral Al in the
resulting material are 70 and 30%, respectively. Three Brønsted sites were identified by a combined Rietveld
refinement that simultaneously employed synchrotron X-ray powder diffraction data and neutron powder
diffraction data. Final lattice parameters were a ) 9.7843(1) Å, b ) 12.3676(1) Å, and c ) 22.8336(2) Å,
the combined R
wp
factor was 6.3%, and l
2
(reduced) was 1.48. Acid deuterons were located approximately 1
Å from oxygens O3, O5, and O7, with occupancy factors of 0.16(2), 0.16(3), and 0.18(2), respectively. These
correpsond to 1.28(16), 0.64(12), and 1.44(16) deuterons per unit cell, respectively, for a total of 3.36(26)
acid sites per unit cell, which is consistent with the tetrahedral Al content. Only deuteron D5 lies on a special
position. T-O bond lengths suggest a site preference for Al at T4, T1, and possibly T2, each of which is
bonded to at least one of the observed acid-site oxygens. A bridging framework oxygen site was identified
in both the PND and PXD difference Fourier maps that appears to be disordered over at least two distinct
sites; this corresponds to different local arrangements of Al at the neighboring T-sites. The out-of-plane
framework hydroxyl tilt angles at each acid site were comparable to those of H
+
SSZ-13 and D
+
RHO. Acid
site D7 demonstrated a significant in-plane hydroxyl tilt angle (7.5°), consistent with ab initio quantum
mechanical calculations. This tilt clearly indicates an Al preference for site T4 over T6.
Introduction
Acidic zeolite catalysts are widely used in the chemical and
petroleum industries for their catalytic activity, their remarkable
reaction selectivity, and their excellent chemical and thermal
stability.
1
Important applications include the isomerization of
xylenes, paraffin hydroisomerization, catalytic cracking, and
heavy oil hydrocracking.
2,3,4
The principal mechanism of acidity
in these materials is the donation of Brønsted acid protons from
bridging framework hydroxyls. Acid protons balance the nega-
tive charge that is acquired by the otherwise neutral framework
when Al
3+
ions occupy some of the tetrahedrally coordinated
Si
4+
sites. Both natural and synthetic aluminosilicate zeolites
can be converted to the acid form from other cationated forms
by ion exchange with an NH
4
salt and subsequent calcination
to remove NH
3
.
A Brønsted acid proton interacts with the framework in a
very different way than do other cations; rather than ionically
coordinating to multiple framework oxygens, it covalently bonds
to one of the oxygens adjacent to a tetrahedral Al atom and
significantly distorts the local framework bonds and angles.
5
Recent computational studies have shown that the geometry of
the framework in the vicinity of an acid site can significantly
influence the formation of the intermediate species that lead to
the final reaction products.
6,7
Ab initio cluster calculations of
ethylene adsorption on a high-silica acid zeolite, for example,
suggest the formation of an intermediate ethoxide that forms a
C-O bond to a nearby framework oxygen.
8,9
Because the local
structure of an acid site controls acidity, accessibility by reactant
molecules, intermediate state formation, and hence the reaction
product, the knowledge of its locations and environments within
the framework is critical to better understanding acid zeolite
catalysis.
Several diffraction-based approaches have been used to
determine the locations of Brønsted acid sites in zeolites and
other silicates. Early inferences were based on average Si-O
bond lengths, as determined by X-ray diffraction,
10
which are
expected to increase upon protonation in proportion to the acid
site occupancy factor. In Ca
3
(SiO
3
OH)
2
(H
2
O)
2
(afwillite) and
Na
2
H
2
(SiO
4
)(H
2
O)
8
, for example, certain Si-O bonds were
observed to be 0.08 Å longer than the others, on average, and
were attributed to the formation of an acidic hydroxyl.
11,12
Based
on these observations, Olson and Dempsey investigated T-O
(T ) Si, Al) distances in acidic zeolite Y (Si/Al ) 2.3) via
single crystal X-ray diffraction, compared them to those of other
acidic faujasite zeolites, and concluded that the O1 and O3 sites
were preferentially protonated while the other framework
oxygens were not.
13
* Corresponding author. Present address: Argonne National Laboratory,
Materials Science Division, Argonne, IL 60439. E-mail: branton@anl.gov.
1947 J. Phys. Chem. B 2001, 105, 1947-1955
10.1021/jp002751t CCC: $20.00 © 2001 American Chemical Society
Published on Web 02/15/2001