ELSEVIER
Free Zones in E1 Salvador
Esteban R. Brenes
INCAE
Vince Ruddy
INCAE
Ren~ Castro
INCAE
In this case study a recent graduate of a Central American MBA program is
confronted with the design,formulation, and evaluation of an international
investment project for establishing a private-sector free trade zone in El
Salvador. The main objective of private and public free trade zones is to
facilitate export-oriented industrial development. Most highly developed
free trade zones around the world offer a variety of benefits to the
companies that operate in them. These benefits include tax exemptions,
duty-free imports, and personnel recruitment services. At the be~nning
of the case, there is a checklist of all the items that should be taken into
account properly to design, prepare, and evaluate a project of this kind.
The case provides information about world demand characteristics for
public and private free trade zones that any company that is potentially
interested in doing business in a free trade zone should take into account.
In addition, it offers ir!lormation about countries offering free trade zones
and how each can compete to attract additional investors. The emphasis
is placed on the Central American region, particularly E1 Salvador and
Costa Rica. El Salvador is the site where the prospective investors are
located, and Costa Rica is considered as an alternative site. When the
case takes place, Costa Rica is considered to be the most advanced in
terms of investments in and development of public and private free trade
zones. The case provides detailed information on both macro and micro
elements. It is therefore expected that the decision will be based not only
on qualitalive considerations, but also on quantitative ones. The macro
elements include the potential impact of changes in incentives granted to
foreign investors and the image c{f instability such changes might convey
to investors. As.for quantitative issues, information in the case is sufficient
to develop a comprehensive financial analysis of the project. The basic
purpose of the case study is to present the major factors to be considered
in making decisions about international site location, including the impor-
tance of macro environmental elements, the site itself, costs, prices, and
market characteristics. The discussion emphasizes the importance of this
Address correspondence to Esteban R. Brenes, INCAE, PO Box 960-4050,
Alajuela, Costa Rica.
Journal of Business Research 38, 57-65 (1997)
© 1997 Elsevier Science Inc.
655 Avenue of the Americas, New York, NY 10010
final element, the market for public and private free trade zones. The
case may also be used to achieve other secondary objectives, such as:
• Understanding the role of the parties involved in the decision
• Calculating the cost of the preinvestment stage
• Understanding some of the typical problems arising from skipping
stages without awaiting final results
• Mastering the use offinancial analysis indicators such as the internal
rate qf return ORR) when a political or country risk is involved.
© 1997 Elsevier Science Inc. I BUSN RES 1997. 38.57--65
U
'pon returning home in January 1992 after finishing
his MBA at a prestigious Latin American school, Mario
Chavez decided to accept the challenge offered to him
by an important Salvadoran business group, PROSAL. The
project consisted of evaluating the feasibility of establishing
a private free zone (PFZ) in E1 Salvador. PROSAL thought
this could be the first investment it could make after a peace
agreement was signed, and if things went well, it could also
be the first of a series of investments in Central America. (See
Appendix A for general information on E1 Salvador.)
The first thing Ch~vez did was to submit a list of activities
to be performed, including the estimated cost to cover his
services for each. He presented his client with the following
proposal:
Prefeasibility study U.S.$5,000
Feasibility study U.S.$15,000
Site design and construction blueprints U.5.$35,000
He also submitted a checklist of the fundamental issues he
would address in his analysis:
ISSN 0148-2963/97/$17.00
PII S0148-2963(96)00118-X