World Journal of Agricultural Research, 2016, Vol. 4, No. 1, 24-30
Available online at http://pubs.sciepub.com/wjar/4/1/4
© Science and Education Publishing
DOI:10.12691/wjar-4-1-4
Effect of Tine Depth and Width on Soil Failure Angle,
Cutting Coefficients and Power in Three-Dimensional
Case: Computer Modeling
Moayad, B. Zaied
1
, Ahmed M. El Naim
2,*
, Omer, A. Abdalla
3
, Abuobieda, M. Sulieman
4
1
Department of Agricultural Engineering, Faculty of Natural Resources and Environmental Studies, University of Kordofan, Elobied, Sudan
2
Department of Crop Sciences, Faculty of Natural Resources and Environmental Studies, University of Kordofan, Elobied, Sudan
3
Department of Agricultural Engineering, Faculty of Agriculture, University of Khartoum, Khartoum, Sudan
4
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Faculty of Engineering and Technical Studies, University of Kordofan, Elobied, Sudan
*Corresponding author: naim17amn@yahoo.com
Abstract The dynamic response of soil to farm implements is a main factor in determining their performance. The
interaction between tillage tools and soil is of a primary interest to the design and use of these tools for soil
manipulation. A computer simulation is conducted by developing a program using C
++
programming language to
study effect of tool depth and width on angle of soil failure plane, soil cutting coefficients, soil resistance force and
Power requirements in three-dimensional soil cutting. The results demonstrated that at 0.2 m tine depth the highest
values of angle of soil failure plane, frictional coefficient, overburden coefficient, soil cohesion coefficient and soil
adhesion coefficient were 52.6°, 19.8, 49.54, 16.47 and 1.38 respectively and they were recorded by 0.04 m tine
width while the lowest values in same sequence were 51.6°, 10.64, 22.05, 7.26 and 1.30 and they were recorded by
0.1 m width. The lowest values of soil resistance force and power were 1.77 kN and 1.03 kW and they were shown
by 0.04 m width while the highest values were 2.07 kN and 2.26 kW and they were demonstrated by 0.1 m width of
tine. At 0.3 m tine depth the highest values of angle of soil failure plane, frictional coefficient, overburden
coefficient, soil cohesion coefficient and soil adhesion coefficient were 52.7°, 27.42, 72.54, 24.11 and 1.39
respectively and they were recorded by 0.04 m tine width while the lowest values in same sequence were 52.3°,
13.70, 31.23, 10.35 and 1.35 and they were recorded by 0.1 m width. The lowest values of soil resistance force and
power were 4.27 kN and 4.66 kW and they were shown by 0.04 m width while the highest values were 4.86 kN and
5.29 kW and they were demonstrated by 0.1 m width of tine. At 0.4 m tine depth the highest values of angle of soil
failure plane, frictional coefficient, overburden coefficient, soil cohesion coefficient and soil adhesion coefficient
were 52.8°, 35.04, 95.27, 31.73 and 1.39 respectively and they were recorded by 0.04 m tine width while the lowest
values in same sequence were 52.5°, 16.75, 40.39, 13.40 and 1.37 and they were recorded by 0.1 m width. The
lowest values of soil resistance force and power were 8.19 kN and 8.93 kW and they were shown by 0.04 m width
while the highest values were 9.13 kN and 9.95 kW and they were demonstrated by 0.1 m width of tine. It was
concluded that Angle of soil failure plane and soil cutting coefficients decreased as tine working depth and width
increased. Soil resistance force and power increased as angle of soil failure plane and soil cutting coefficients
decreased as tine working depth and width increased.
Keywords: computer modeling, soil three dimensional cutting
Cite This Article: Moayad, B. Zaied, Ahmed M. El Naim, Omer, A. Abdalla, and Abuobieda, M. Sulieman,
“Effect of Tine Depth and Width on Soil Failure Angle, Cutting Coefficients and Power in Three-Dimensional
Case: Computer Modeling.” World Journal of Agricultural Research, vol. 4, no. 1 (2016): 24-30. doi:
10.12691/wjar-4-1-4.
1. Introduction
Limit equilibrium is one of the most important approaches
used to analyze soil–tool systems. Two most important
factors in the approach are the shape of soil failure surface,
and equilibrium equations, which are two or three
dimensional cases. Several mathematical models have
been developed for predicting the performance characteristics
of tillage tools in soils. These include two-dimensional
models for wide tools and three dimensional models for
narrow tillage tools. Payne's model [1] was the first three-
dimensional soil failure model By observing the top
surface soil heave during tillage, a failure zone was
proposed The failure zone included a triangular centre
wedge, a centre crescent, and two side blocks (called
wings of the crescent).
Extensive tests were conducted by Payne and Tanner [2]
to study the effects of the failure zone size and the rake
angle on the draft force. However, no equations were
developed to evaluate the draft force for narrow tillage
tools. The analysis of three-dimensional failure assumes