Early prediction of outcomes in hip fractures: initial fracture
displacement
Özgür Baysal, Engin Eceviz, Güven Bulut and Halil İbrahim Bekler
We retrospectively analyzed the surgical treatment of 28
pediatric hip fractures. The majority of cases were Delbet
type 2 (57%) and type 3 (29%). The average age of the
patients was 10.8 years (range: 2–16 years). The mean
follow-up period was 91 months. Displaced fractures were
found in 18 cases (64%). The major factor in the
development of avascular necrosis was the degree of
displacement at the time of initial presentation (P < 0.05),
irrespective of fracture type. Although the degree of initial
displacement cannot be prevented, careful exposure of soft
tissue during open reduction will reduce avascular
necrosis. J Pediatr Orthop B 25:228–233 Copyright © 2016
Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. All rights reserved.
Journal of Pediatric Orthopaedics B 2016, 25:228–233
Keywords: hip fractures, initial displacement, outcomes, pediatric trauma
Department of Orthopaedic and Traumatology, Lütfi Kirdar Kartal Training and
Research Hospital, Istanbul, Turkey
Correspondence to Özgür Baysal, MD, Semsi Denizer Avenue E5 Highway,
Cevizli - Kartal, Istanbul 34890, Turkey
Tel: + 90 216 4413900/1421; fax: + 90 216 3055110;
e-mail: drozgurbaysal@gmail.com
Introduction
Although the majority of pediatric fractures heal without
difficulty using conservative treatment methods, femoral
neck fractures require a different approach from the
diagnosis stage forwards. Although these fractures are
rarely seen, they can cause complications that may have
life-long negative effects [1–13].
Following pediatric hip fractures, complications can occur
such as avascular necrosis, nonunion, malunion, and
shortness because of early physeal closure. Subsequently,
infection, skin problems, and chondrolysis may develop
associated with the treatment [14]. As these complica-
tions lead to functional disability, the patient must be
closely monitored from the time of the fracture until
complete bone union.
Complications following a hip fracture are not deter-
mined by any single parameter. The quality of results
varies depending on the initial amount of fracture dis-
placement, the fracture type, the age of the patient, the
time of fixation, the type and quality of reduction, and
the type and number of fixation materials [7].
Avascular necrosis is the most frequently encountered
and most serious complication following fractures of the
proximal femur [14]. Primarily, the medial circumflex
artery and the arteria femoris capitis provide the blood
supply to the femoral neck region. The metaphyseal
vessels providing the blood supply along the length of
the femur toward the femoral head are absent at
15–18 months during physis development [13]. In addi-
tion, the lateral circumflex artery is not evident until the
age of 3 years. This tenuous blood supply to the femoral
head is a direct cause of poor functional results after
femoral neck fracture. The development of avascular
necrosis is directly related to the initial fracture dis-
placement or the displacement following reduction
[14–16]. In pediatric hip fractures, the damage to the
vessels providing the blood supply to the femoral head is
proportional to the degree of fracture displacement and it
is the most significant risk factor triggering the develop-
ment of avascular necrosis.
In this study, we examined the long-term results and
complications of pediatric femoral neck fractures asso-
ciated with degree of initial displacement, fracture type,
method of treatment, duration of treatment, and the
number and types of implants used.
Methods
A retrospective evaluation was performed of 35 pediatric
patients with hip fractures who were surgically treated
between 1997 and 2013.
Of those patients, 28 were included in the study. A total
of seven patients were excluded from the study because
of factors that could negatively affect bone healing and
functional results. Four patients had pathological frac-
tures (tumors or bone cyst), two patients had cerebral
palsy (evidence of osteoporosis), and one patient had a
crush injury with an open fracture from an earthquake
injury.
Delbet classifications of fractures were determined: type
1 – two patients (7%), type 2 – 16 patients (57%), type 3 –
eight patients (29%), and type 4 – two patients (7%).
Thus, the majority of fractures (86%) were type 2 and
type 3. If there was fracture line cortical continuity in the
anteroposterior and lateral radiographic planes in the
proximal femur, the fracture was defined as non-
displaced. If the cortical continuity was separate from the
228 Original article
1060-152X Copyright © 2016 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. All rights reserved. DOI: 10.1097/BPB.0000000000000263
Copyright r 2016 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. All rights reserved.