RESEARCH LETTER
Prenatal serum screening markers may not require adjustment
in former smokers
Geralyn Lambert-Messerlian* and Glenn E. Palomaki
Department of Pathology and Laboratory Medicine, Women and Infants Hospital and Alpert Medical School of Brown University, Providence, RI, USA
*Correspondence to: Geralyn Lambert-Messerlian. E-mail: gmesserl@wihri.org
Funding sources: None
Conflicts of interest: Dr. Messerlian has received grant and travel support from Ansh Labs (Webster, TX). Dr. Palomaki has received grant, service and consulting fees
through contracts between Women and Infants Hospital and Beckman Coulter (Chaska, MN), Ansh Labs (Webster, TX), PerkinElmer (Waltham, MA) and LabCorp
(Burlington, NC).
Cigarette smoking has been shown to have a significant impact
on maternal serum markers used in prenatal screening.
Smokers, on average, have higher second trimester maternal
serum alpha-fetoprotein (AFP) and inhibin A (inhA) levels,
and lower unconjugated estriol (uE3) and beta-human
chorionic gonadotrophin (hCG) levels.
1–5
The first trimester
serum markers, pregnancy-associated plasma protein-A
(PAPP-A) and hCG are also reduced in smokers.
3,5–7
Adjusting
serum marker levels for smoking status has proven to be
helpful in avoiding high screen positive rates, especially for
trisomy 18 when using first trimester or integrated testing.
8
Prenatal screening requisition slips are occasionally received
in the laboratory with handwritten notes from the practitioners.
Some inform the laboratory that the patient has recently quit
smoking cigarettes. Our protocol routinely treats these patients
as non-smokers for the purposes of interpreting and reporting
results, but no evidence for this action is available. Our objective
was to conduct a retrospective examination of prenatal screening
records to determine whether serum screening marker levels
should be adjusted in former smokers.
All first and second trimester screening requisitions received
at Women and Infants Hospital in 2014 were included. The
clinical database included identification of smokers and non-
smokers. Original requisition slips were reviewed to find
women who reported being a former smoker, and this
information was added to the database. First trimester
PAPP-A and hCG had been measured upon sample receipt
using a manual enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (Ansh
Labs, Webster, TX) and an automated chemiluminescent
method on the DxI instrument (Beckman Coulter, Inc.,
Chaska, MN), respectively. Second trimester AFP, uE3, hCG
and inhibin A were also measured on the DxI. Demographic
data on gestational age (by LMP or ultrasound), maternal
weight, race and diabetic status were used in calculation of
marker multiples of the median (MoM) values according to
published methods using Alpha software (Logical Medical
Systems, London, UK). This study was considered exempt from
review by the Institutional Review Board for Human Studies at
Women and Infants Hospital.
Serum marker levels were expressed as MoM and were
adjusted for maternal weight, race, presence of insulin-
dependent diabetes and for changes known to be associated
with in vitro fertilization. For the purposes of this analysis,
results were not adjusted for smoking status. We then compared
MoM levels between smokers, non-smokers and those who were
former cigarette smokers. The analyses focused on the first
trimester PAPP-A and second trimester hCG and inhA. Cigarette
smoking has the largest impact on these analyte levels, and these
analytes have the largest number of observations available for
analysis (e.g. first trimester hCG measurements are uncommon
in our screening program). The expected effect for the other
analytes is much smaller (e.g. reduction of uE3 levels of 4%
among smokers).
8
The overall median MoM levels were set to
1.00 by dividing each patient MoM by the observed median
MoM for all patients in the clinical database (1.01, 1.03 and
1.01, for PAPP-A, hCG and InhA, respectively).
In 2014, there were 10 843 screening records from patients
with a singleton pregnancy. Of these, 717 (6.6%) had only
AFP measurements for open neural tube defect screening,
and another 725 (6.7%) had no information recorded for
smoking status. All were removed, with the remaining 9392
records subject to analysis. Overall, 8765 (93.3%) were non-
smokers, 555 (5.9%) reported smoking cigarettes and 69
(0.7%) reported that they had stopped smoking cigarettes.
Among this latter group of women, 31 (45%) reported being
‘former’ smokers or had ‘quit’ smoking, with no further details.
Another 35 reported quitting within the last 2 months before
the initial sample was tested, and the final three women
reported quitting more than 2 months before the initial sample
was tested. Forty-four records were from women having
Prenatal Diagnosis 2015, 35, 1371–1373 © 2015 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
DOI: 10.1002/pd.4695