Soil Tillage, Conservation & Management
1124 Agronomy Journal • Volume 103, Issue 4 • 2011
Western Oregon Grass Seed Crop Rotation
and Straw Residue Effects on Soil Quality
S. M. Grif fith,* G. M. Banowetz, R. P. Dick, G. W. Mueller-Warrant,
and G. W. Whittaker
Published in Agron. J. 103:1124–1131 (2011)
Posted online 11 May 2011
doi:10.2134/agronj2010.0504
Copyright © 2011 by the American Society of Agronomy, 5585 Guilford
Road, Madison, WI 53711. All rights reserved. No part of this periodical may
be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or
mechanical, including photocopying, recording, or any information storage
and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher.
W
estern Oregon’s Willamette Valley is the
largest producer of cool-season forage and turfgrass seed
in the world. Approximately 194,000 ha in the region are devoted
to production of grass seed crops because the soils do not supply
sufficient drainage suitable for conventional crops. Western
Oregon’s marine climate and poorly drained soils offer a unique
environment to study dryland crop production and soil quality
due to the mild temperatures and quantities of annual precipi-
tation that oſten cause semi-flooded field conditions. No such
climatic and soil conditions like this exist elsewhere in the world.
For decades field burning removed postharvest straw residue in
grass seed production systems of the Pacific Northwest (PNW)
but legislative action to enhance air quality phased out burn-
ing almost completely between 1991 and 1997. is change in
production practices spurred greater use of nonthermal cropping
practices, such as baling and removal of postharvest straw or incor-
poration into the soil, as well as crop rotations to increase crop
species diversity. Seed yield of perennial ryegrass and tall fescue
was greatest with direct seeding, while that of creeping red fescue
was unaffected by tillage method (Nelson et al., 2006; Steiner et
al., 2006). Further, seed yield from all three crops was unaffected
by residue management (residue remaining vs. baled). Steiner et al.
(2006), using the Revised Universal Soil Loss Equation (RUSLE),
calculated that direct seeding and high straw return reduced
soil erosion and determined that it cost less to implement than
conventional tillage and low straw by baling and removal. Further,
Nelson et al. (2006) reported that relative to conventionally tilled
soil, soil microbial biomass carbon (MB
C
) was 20 to 30% higher
under direct seeding, regardless of soil drainage class or time of
year. ey also reported that a study location in Marion County,
Oregon had twice the amount of MB
C
compared to a site in
Benton County, Oregon. Crop N uptake was lowest in the fall and
highest when soil N was elevated in the spring. Tillage enhanced
annual total net N mineralization at the better-drained location
growing creeping red fescue for seed resulting in potentially greater
leachable nitrate during the following winter high precipitation
months (November–February) when the crop’s demand for N is
low due to slow growth and suboptimal temperatures (Nelson et
al., 2006). Tillage had little effect on net N mineralization at the
poorly drained site at Linn County, Oregon.
Steiner et al. (2006) reported several conservation measures that
could be implemented into western Oregon grass seed produc-
tion systems to benefit the grower financially, as well as improving
ecosystem services and farm sustainability. Due to complex grower
constraints when growing certified seed, such as meeting seed
certification standards while simultaneously conserving farmland
and managing pests and weeds, full adoption of conservation
ABSTRACT
Understanding the impact of crop rotation and residue management in grass seed production systems on soil quality and, in particular
soil C dynamics, is critical in making long-term soil management decisions supporting farm sustainability. e effects of a 6-yr rota-
tion and residue management (high vs. low residue) on soil quality were investigated at three locations in Oregon, each contrasting in
soil drainage classification. e crop rotations were continuous perennial grass seed production, grass/legume seed production, and
grass/legume/cereal seed production. e grass species grown at each location were different and represented those most commonly
produced in each environment; perennial ryegrass (Lolium perenne L.), tall fescue [Schedonorus phoenix (Scop.) Holub], and creeping
red fescue (Festuca rubra L.). All three grass seed crop rotations and residue methods maintained high soil quality in conventional or
direct seeded soils, but under some situations, soil quality was higher with continuous grass rotation and high residue. Data suggest that
straw removal for value-added use, like bioenergy production, can be accomplished in the Pacific Northwest Marine climate without
appreciably affecting soil quality. Furthermore, grass seed cropping systems play an important role in soil C storage and enhancement,
a valuable ecosystem service in this region where grass seed is produced on land that is not suitable for production of conventional crops
that require better-drained soil. We conclude that by nature perennial grass seed crops promote high soil fertility and enriched soil C
pools and consequently contribute to the tolerance of these systems to the use of less conservation-oriented crop management methods
at times when crop loss could be potentially high. is attribute provides producers greater latitude in selecting soil and crop manage-
ment options to address issues of soil fertility, pest, weed, or seed certification to minimize economic crop yield losses.
S.M. Griffith, G.M. Banowetz, G.W. Mueller-Warrant, and G.W. Whittaker,
USDA-ARS, NFSPRC, 3450 SW Campus Way, Corvallis, OR 97331; R.P. Dick,
Ohio State Univ., School of Environment and Natural Resources, Columbus, OH
43210. Received 13 Dec. 2010. *Corresponding author (griffits@onid.orst.edu).
Abbreviations: DOC, dissolved organic carbon; G, continuous grass seed
production; GL, grass/legume seed production; GLC, grass/legume/cereal
seed production; HR, high residue; LR, low residue; MB
c
, microbial biomass
carbon; PNW, Pacific Northwest; POM, particulate organic matter; SOM, soil
organic matter; SPR, soil penetration resistance; WSA, water stable aggregates.
Published online July, 2011