Neglected Rupture of the Achilles Tendon
Treated With Peroneus Brevis Transfer:
A Functional Assessment of 5 Cases
Mladen Miskulin,
1
Andrea Miškulin,
2
Hrvoje Klobucˇ ar,
3
and Slobodan Kuvalja
4
The purpose of this study was to review the clinical results of 5 patients who underwent repair of a
chronic Achilles tendon rupture using a combination of peroneus brevis transfer and plantaris tendon
augmentation. The technique belongs to the group of local tendon transfer procedures making use of the
transferred peroneus brevis tendon as strengthening material together with the plantaris tendon as
suturing material. There were 4 males and 1 female with an average age of 49.4 years and an average time
to presentation postinjury of 19.8 weeks (range 5– 40 wk). All patients underwent Cybex strength testing
before and approximately 1 year after surgery. This testing demonstrated a postoperative improvement
in peak plantarflexion torque (Newton-meters/body weight) in all cases. The peak torque of plantar flexion
increased in all patients (range, 21%– 410%). Four patients were found to have an increase of the dorsal
flexors peak torque (range, 31%–290%), whereas one patient showed a decrease (37%). No patient
experienced wound closure complications, postoperative pain, or functional limitations. In spite the
possibility of residual lateral ankle instability, we found this modification to be a valuable innovation that
offers a very good functional result, low morbidity, technical advantages to the surgeon and, most
important, a durable and satisfactory result for the patients. ( The Journal of Foot & Ankle Surgery 44(1):
49-56, 2005)
Key words: Achilles tendon, neglected rupture, peroneus brevis transfer, plantaris transfer, Cybex
isokinetic test
T he neglected Achilles tendon rupture refers to a rupture
with a delay in diagnosis or treatment of more than than 4
weeks after injury (1). Most authors agree that surgical
treatment offers better functional results than conservative
measures for these patients (1–20). However, reconstruction
of these cases has always been a challenge for surgeons
because of the large tendon defect and the many technical
difficulties involved in achieving a successful result. Major
procedural concerns include tendon retraction, scar tissue
bridging the gap, disturbed blood supply following certain
procedures (such as the V-Y tendinous flap), and potential
wound closure problems (2, 4, 21–25).
The surgeon is therefore faced with the difficult decision
as to which of the many proposed treatments would best
serve the patient. Several surgical methods of treatment
have been described and can be divided into 5 major groups:
local tissue augmentation with plantaris tendon; V-Y ad-
vancement; local tendon transfer (peroneus brevis, flexor
digitorum longus, flexor hallucis longus); free tissue trans-
fer (fascia lata, free flaps, patellar bone tendon grafts, allo-
grafts); and use of synthetic materials such as Dacron vas-
cular grafts (Invista, Wichita, KS), carbon fiber composites,
proteoglycol threads, or Marlex mesh (Davol, Cranston, RI)
(4 –12, 14 –16, 18 –20, 23, 26).
Historically, peroneus brevis transfer was proposed as a
surgical treatment for the acute Achilles tendon rupture by
Teuffer in 1974 (7). Using a similar procedure, Hepp and
Blauth (22) confirmed good to excellent results, especially
in the difficult cases with large defects and unfavorable
anatomic conditions. Turco and Spinella (8) reported results
of the direct end-to-end suture of the ruptured Achilles
tendon combined with the transfer of the peroneus brevis,
passing it through a calcaneal drill hole. The results were
satisfactory, but many procedures were performed on the
patients who had acute rupture or chronic rupture with little
diastasis of tendon ends (27).
In recent years, results of the various reconstruction pro-
cedures were evaluated, not only by physical examination
but also by objective methods—instrumented strength test-
ing using Cybex isokinetic dynamometer (Cybex Interna-
tional, Inc, Medway, MA) and gait analysis (2, 27–33). We
are unaware of any studies that have documented the results
of the peroneus brevis transfer procedure. Therefore, the
Address correspondence to: Mladen Miskulin, Zelengaj 45 c, 10000
Zagreb, Croatia. E-mail: mladen.miskulin@zg.hinet.hr
1
Sveti Duh Hospital, Zagreb, Croatia.
2
Etela Rehabilitation Center, Zagreb, Croatia.
3
Orthopaedic Department, University of Zagreb, Zagreb, Croatia.
4
Cybex Center, Zagreb, Croatia
Copyright © 2005 by the American College of Foot and Ankle Surgeons
1067-2516/05/4401-0008$30.00/0
doi:10.1016/j.jfas.2004.11.003
VOLUME 44, NUMBER 1, JANUARY/FEBRUARY 2005 49