Improving Safety Messages Dissemination in IEEE
802.11e Based VANETs Using Controlled Repetition
Technique
Ghazal Farrokhi, Saadan Zokaei and Ebrahim Ghazisaeedi
Electrical and Computer Engineering Department
K. N. Toosi University of Technology
Tehran, Iran
ghfarrokhi@ee.kntu.ac.ir, szokaei@eetd.kntu.ac.ir,
eghazisaeedi@ieee.org
Mehdi Khabazian
INRS-EMT
University of Quebec
Montreal, QC, Canada
khaba@emt.inrs.ca
Abstract— Vehicular ad hoc networks (VANETs) have been
proposed to provide safety and non-safety services for the
passengers on board. Reliability in broadcasting of safety
messages is one of the fundamental challenges in the design of
such networks. In this paper, we study the impact of
employment of repetition and piggybacking techniques on the
performance of safety messages dissemination in an IEEE
802.11e-based VANET. The adequacy of the proposed
techniques has been evaluated by a simulation. The results of
this simulation show that the performance of VANET
improves by setting proper parameters and the number of
repetitions per priority class. Further, controlling the number
of repetitions by piggyback technique can highly improve the
performance of VANET for broadcasting of safety messages.
Keywords- VANETs; Safety messages; IEEE 802.11e;
Repetition Technique; Piggyback Technique (Controlled
Repetition Communication).
I. INTRODUCTION
Vehicular ad hoc Networks are forms of mobile ad hoc
network, which provide communications among vehicles or
between vehicles and fixed roadside equipments. VANETs
are equipped with short-range to medium-range
communication systems and their prospective applications
include safety and comfort applications which share the
wireless channel with mobile applications from a large,
decentralized array of service providers. Examples of
vehicular safety applications include collision avoidance,
lane changing assistant and other safety warning services.
Non-safety applications include traffic congestion avoidance,
alternative route proposal, high-speed tolling and mobile
infotainment. Due to the VANETs unique characteristics,
such as scalability, high robustness expectation, strict delay
requirements and security issues, the design of such a
technology becomes an extraordinary challenge for the
wireless research community.
As a standardization approach, Dedicated short range
communication (DSRC) standard licensed 75 MHz of
frequency spectrum at 5.9 GHz band to support low-latency
wireless data communications among vehicles and from
vehicle to roadside units in USA [1-3]. Essentially, DSRC
radio technology is based on IEEE802.11a which is adjusted
for low overhead operations in DSRC spectrum and is being
standardized as IEEE802.11p [2-4]. Due to the highly
dynamic topology and the stringent delay requirements,
safety applications usually need a one hop ad hoc
communication [5]. In the following, we review some of the
available studies on MAC layer which tackle the reliability
issues in the message disseminations in VANET.
In [6], the authors propose several single-hop broadcast
protocols to improve reception reliability and channel
throughput. Torrent-Moreno et al. [7] proposes a priority
access scheme for IEEE 802.11-based vehicular ad hoc
networks and show that the broadcast reception probability
can become very low under saturation conditions. Jiang et al.
[8] raises channel congestion control issues for vehicular
safety communication, and introduce feedback information
to enhance system performance and reliability. ElBatt et al.
[9] discusses the suitability of DSRC periodic broadcast
message for cooperative collision warning application. None
of the above studies consider a message priority scheme. [10-
13] are among those few studies which consider message
priorities in their analysis. In [10], the authors proposed
priority Carrier Sense Multiple Access (P-CSMA) and
polling P-CSMA (PP-CSMA). However, the protocol is not
compatible with the IEEE 802.11 and IEEE 802.11e
standards. In some recent papers, such as [11], repetition
techniques are proposed for priority-based scenarios;
however no optimized value is derived for the number of
transmission repetitions. In fact, a high number of repetitions
increase the collisions in the network, and as a result, the
performance of the network degrades. In [12], the authors
propose the piggyback cooperative idea for controlling the
collision rates. In [13], we considered a controlled repetition
technique for car-to-car and car-to-infrastructure
communications in a network with a fixed number of
vehicles. In that study it has been shown that using this
framework we can provide better reliability for important
safety messages in VANETs.
This work extends the results of [13] in several
directions. First of all, we enhance the repetition-based
broadcasting mechanism by applying a piggyback technique
2010 Sixth International Conference on Wireless and Mobile Communications
978-0-7695-4182-2/10 $26.00 © 2010 IEEE
DOI 10.1109/ICWMC.2010.51
395
2010 Sixth International Conference on Wireless and Mobile Communications
978-0-7695-4182-2/10 $26.00 © 2010 IEEE
DOI 10.1109/ICWMC.2010.51
395