Conflict resolution in online mental health
support groups
The role of empathy and informal mediation
Carolina Figueras Bates
University of Barcelona
The literature on online mental health support groups usually stresses the
harmonious side of users’ interactions. However, differences regarding the
experience of the illness might escalate into social conflict. The aim of this
study is to explore acts of conflict resolution in an online Spanish mental
health forum for recovery from an eating disorder (ED). Focusing on a
specific long dispute between one regular contributor and several other
members, I perform a micro-analysis of the discursive moves deployed in
this polylogue by those who act as informal mediators to mitigate negative
emotions, to rephrase participants’ perspectives and to promote relational
empathy within the group. The goal of mediation in the forum is to reinstate
the social order of acceptable recovery practices and discourses.
Keywords: online forums, emotional support, empathy, conflict, informal
mediation, eating disorders, recovery
1. Introduction
Since the advent of the Internet, computer-mediated peer-to-peer support groups
for a variety of health issues have been proliferating. These virtual communities
offer their users a platform for legitimacy and recognition, as well as a social net-
work for sharing knowledge and experience (McCormack and Coulson 2009).
Online health groups may vary regarding degrees of professional assistance,
norms, and ideology, but they all embrace the needs of the self-help movement:
promote empowerment, facilitate peer support, and exchange experiential knowl-
edge (Kummervold et al. 2002).
Online forums have a long history, and although at present they are not as
popular as they were ten years ago, they are still frequently visited and regularly
consulted by individuals with a variety of different mental health conditions (see
https://doi.org/10.1075/ld.00171.fig | Published online: 13 June 2024
Language and Dialogue ISSN 2210-4119 | E‑ISSN 2210-4127 © John Benjamins Publishing Company