*Corresponding author: Swati Gupta
Department of Education, Aligarh Muslim University, U.P
ISSN: 0976-3031
RESEARCH ARTICLE
EVALUATION OF STATISTICAL METHODS USED IN PH.D. THESES OF SOCIAL
SCIENCES IN INDIAN UNIVERSITIES
Punita Govil
1
, Mamun Ali Naji Qasem
2
and Swati Gupta
3
*
1,3
Department of Education, Aligarh Muslim University, U.P
2
Member of Faculty of Education, Ibb University, Yemen
ARTICLE INFO ABSTRACT
Article History:
Received 14
th
, February, 2015
Received in revised form 23
th
,
February, 2015
Accepted 13
th
, March, 2015
Published online 28
th
,
March, 2015
The study was aimed at finding out the suitability of statistical methods used in the analysis of the data in
Ph.D. theses of social science faculty in Indian Universities. It was also the purpose of the study to find
out the types of common errors committed by the researchers while using statistical methods to analyze
the data in Ph.D. theses. For the purpose, a standardized tool developed by the researchers was used by
the investigators to evaluate the statistical methods used in theses of social science faculty. The sample
consisted of 20 Ph.D. theses of social science faculty of Indian Universities including 120 statistical
methods. In the sample, 10 theses from Department of Education and 10 theses from Psychology
Department in faculty of Social Sciences of AMU were randomly selected. The analysis of the study
revealed that: (1)79% of the studies have employed appropriate method according to sample size and
number of variables and 77% of the theses have employed appropriate method according to research
design. However, only 47% of the researchers fulfilled the assumptions of the method used by them. (2)
The common errors committed by the researchers while using statistical methods are of serious nature.
None of the researchers calculated effect size in his/her thesis. 87% of the evaluated theses did not select
the sample in appropriate manner and 36% of the researchers of social sciences used insufficient
statistical methods in their theses.
Key words:
Statistics, Parametric and Non-
Parametric methods
Copyright © Swati Gupta et al., This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License,
which permits unrestricted use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
INTRODUCTION
The term ‘Research’ in general usage refers to a search for
knowledge. Hansen (2009) defined it as creative work
undertaken on a systematic basis in order to increase the
knowledge, including knowledge of man, culture and society
and the use of this knowledge to devise new applications. It is
also defined as the creation of new knowledge or the use of
existing knowledge in a new and creative way so as to generate
new concepts, methodologies and understandings.
Research is not confined to science and technology only. There
are vast areas of research in other disciplines such as
Humanities, Arts and Social Sciences. Educational research is
the systematic application of scientific method for solving the
educational problems. It uses both conceptions of social reality
and the statistical methods that are considered appropriate for
exploring it. The statistical methods are technically very
essential in the realm of the research. They help in analyzing
the data and to draw out the conclusions more clearly, precisely
and more accurately (Rajasekar & et al, 2013). Thus statistics
is the rule of scientific research and without the rules and
procedures for collecting data it would be difficult to draw
valid and reliable conclusions. Statistics is the science and
practice of developing human knowledge through the use of
empirical data expressed in quantitative form. This discipline is
based on sound theories and is a branch of applied
mathematics. Within statistical theory, randomness and
uncertainty are modeled by probability theory. In other words,
a researcher can make suitable decisions on research in terms
of accepting or rejecting the proposed hypotheses using
statistical tools. For that matter, being able to use statistics in
research, the required processes and skills for each kind of
research is necessary for every researcher so that correct
conclusions may be drawn.
Statement of the problem
Briefly, the present study seeks to “Evaluate Statistical
Methods used in Ph.D. Theses of Social Sciences in Indian
Universities” so that quality of the theses carried out in the
universities in the area of social sciences may be assessed.
In other words, the present study tries to find out the answer of
following questions:
1. What are the statistical methods used generally in the
analysis of the data in Ph.D. theses of social sciences in
Indian Universities?
2. Do the researchers use the suitable statistical methods in
the analysis of the data in Ph.D. theses of social sciences
in Indian Universities?
Available Online at http://www.recentscientific.com
International Journal
of Recent Scientific
Research
International Journal of Recent Scientific Research
Vol. 6, Issue, 3, pp.2926-2931, March, 2015