1 3
J Immigrant Minority Health
DOI 10.1007/s10903-016-0520-1
ORIGINAL PAPER
Stage Validity of the Health Action Process Approach in African
American Breast Cancer Survivors
Rachel Meadows
1
· Raheem J. Paxton
2
© Springer Science+Business Media New York 2016
stage- or phase-based interventions can be designed for this
population.
Keywords Breast cancer · African American · Health
behavior · Physical activity · Cancer survivorship ·
Validity · Stage of change
Introduction
Physical activity (PA) is associated with several benefits
for cancer survivors including improvements in cancer-
related fatigue, emotional well-being, sleep disturbances,
pain, physical functioning, cardio-respiratory fitness, and
reductions in body mass index [1–6]. Despite the benefits,
many cancer survivors do not meet current PA guidelines
and African Americans report the lowest compliance rates
among cancer survivors [7–9]. Inactivity among African
American cancer survivors contributes significantly to the
cancer-related disparities that exist among African Ameri-
can and non-Hispanic White survivor populations [10].
Literature documenting the correlates of PA in breast
cancer survivors has focused almost exclusively on non-
Hispanic White survivor samples, while fewer studies have
addressed the correlates of PA in minority cancer survivors
[5, 11–15]. African American breast cancer survivors are
in desperate need of studies that document the correlates
of PA as well as effective behavior change strategies. The
limited data that exist on effective behavior change strate-
gies in minority cancer survivors suggests a need for more
theory research in this population [16, 17].
Prior studies in cancer survivors have focused on frame-
works such as the Social Cognitive Theory, Health Belief
Model, and Theory of Planned Behavior [18–20]. Recently,
the Health Action Process Approach (HAPA) was shown to
Abstract The Health Action Process Approach (HAPA)
has been applied in a number of populations because it
proposes to overcome limitations from previous health
behavior theories. However, it has yet to be applied to can-
cer survivors or racial/ethnic minorities. In this study, we
examined the construct validity of the HAPA phase and
stage algorithms in a sample of African American breast
cancer survivors. A total of 259 African American breast
cancer survivors (mean age = 54 years) participated in a
Web-based survey that assessed sociodemographic and
medical characteristics, physical activity, and HAPA con-
structs. Analysis of covariance was used to compare mean
differences between HAPA phase/stage. Statistical signifi-
cance was determined at p < 0.017 due to multiple com-
parisons. Phase and stage inconsistencies were observed
for most constructs. However, adequate distinctions were
made for motivational self-efficacy and intentions (i.e.,
P = I < A) by phase, and both action and coping planning
(i.e., P < I < A) by stage. Our data indicate partial sup-
port of the HAPA algorithm to classify African American
breast cancer survivors according to stage or phase. Modi-
fying the staging algorithm or constructs are needed if
* Rachel Meadows
meadows.262@osu.edu
Raheem J. Paxton
Raheem.Paxton@unthsc.edu
1
Comprehensive Cancer Center, Center for Population Health
and Health Disparities and the College of Public Health,
The Ohio State University, 1590 N. High Street, Suite 525,
Columbus, OH 43201, USA
2
Institute of Healthy Aging and the School of Public Health,
The University of North Texas Health Science Center, 3500
Camp Bowie Blvd, Fort Worth, TX 76107, USA