WALIA journal 34(1): 211-218, 2018
Available online at www.Waliaj.com
ISSN 1026-3861
© 2018 WALIA
211
Linking strategic complexity to management decision making in
SMEs: Mediation of organizational flexibility
Syeda Rizwana Hussain Tirmizi
1, *
, Muhammad Yasir
1
, Suleman Shah
2
1
Department of Management Sciences, Hazara University Mansehra, Pakistan
2
Department of Management Sciences, University of East London, United Kingdom
Abstract: This paper aims to investigate the linkage among strategic complexity and management decision making
in SMEs. Additionally, the mediating influence of organizational flexibility was also examined in the above
hypothesized linkage. Data was collected through a survey instrument from 976 SMEs owners and managers. Data
were analyzed through correlations and regressions analyses following Barron and Kenny’s (1986) procedure for
establishing mediation. The findings show that strategic complexity and organizational flexibility have a
significantly positive linkage with SMEs management decision making. However, the linkages of strategic
complexities and management decision making become insignificant in the presence of organizational flexibilities,
which affirmed that organizational flexibility has significant and immediate mediating effects in the relationships of
strategic complexities and SMEs management decisions making in Pakistan. This study was underpinned to the
complexity theory (Monroy, 2003), and have important theoretical and methodological contributions to SMEs
research.
Key words: Strategic complexity; Organizational flexibility; Management decision making; SMEs
1. Introduction
*
SMEs constitutes about more than 90 percent
businesses all over the world. Furthermore, they
provide more than 60 percent of employment (Raza
and Majid, 2015). However, Zimmerer, Scarborough
and Wilson (2005) reported that most of the
businesses particularly SMEs are unsuccessful from
the last few years. This demonstrates business
failure is an immense issue of SME. Many
investigations have proposed that business
malfunction is expected to a great extent to a
business’s inability to decisions making
management. As Zimmerer, Scarborough and Wilson
(2005) noted that without an obviously
characterized system, a business has no practical
reason for making and keeping up a focused
periphery in the commercial center. This outlook is
common in various exact studies that uncover a
connection among decision making and businesses
achievement (e.g. Schwenk, 1988; Gibson et al, 2002;
Rue and Ibrahim, 1998). Management decision
making is consequently an imperative research
theme for organizational achievement. Research has
demonstrated that the higher level malfunction rate
of small enterprises, especially of new companies,
may be ascribed to the absence of recognized
businesses management decision making
(Castrogiovanni, 1996). In spite of the important
contributions by SME in the Pakistani financial
*
Corresponding Author.
system, no research has been conducted on SMEs
regarding decision making notion.
Decision making referred to the activity or
procedure of settling on essential decisions
regarding organizations (Papadakis and Barwise,
2012), while management decision making refers to
significant actions taken while considering firm
resources and precedents sets (Mintzberg,
Raisinghani and Theoret, 1976). Humans govern
organizations and they are also responsible for
organizational decisions, which in turn give actions
of organizations. By review necessary literature of
SMEs it is revealed that principal decisions makers of
SMEs are their owners which also constitute the top
level management of the organization in most cases
(O' Dwyer, Gilmore and Carson, 2009). On an
identical note, Boxer, Perren and Berry (2013)
argued that top management team of SMEs with
higher job related heterogeneity having higher
capability of strategic thinking. When a manager take
decisions at top level management in the
organizations, sometimes it is considered effective
for organization and sometimes it may be criticize. It
means that complexities arise, and these
complexities have influence on decision making of
organizations.
Complexities play an important role in the
organizational decisions making. There are different
roles which complexity dimensions plays in the
stable environment of organization. As observed by
Geraldi, Maylor and Williams (2011) the very idea of
complexity is related to the internal elements of
organizations. This type of complexity is made more