SOUTH ASIA
RESEARCH
www.sagepublications.com
DOI: 10.1177/0262728012469387
Vol. 32(3): 233–256
Copyright © 2012
SAGE Publications
Los Angeles,
London,
New Delhi,
Singapore and
Washington DC
LITERARY SELF-DETERMINATION AND
THE DISCIPLINARY BOUNDARIES OF
HINDI LITERATURE IN THE EARLY
TWENTIETH CENTURY
Sujata S. Mody
Department of Foreign Languages & Literatures,
North Carolina State University, Raleigh, USA
abstract This article examines Mahavir Prasad Dwivedi’s project
of literary self-determination, as articulated in two programmatic
essays published in the Hindi journal Sarasvati under his editorship
(1903–1920), scrutinising his construction of literature as a
culturally embedded category of national consequence. His
theorisation of Hindi literature as broadly inclusive in terms of
its basic definition and function supported the growth of what he
considered a national treasury of literature. His discussion of its
historical and linguistic parameters and his emphasis on a prioritised
plan of literary production, reified the notion of a modern discipline
oriented towards a narrowly constructed national collective that
sought to establish its sovereign identity via literature in Khari Boli
Hindi. Though not explicit in its anti-colonial nationalism, this
project nevertheless privileged Hindi as the projected lead language
of a modern sovereign nation, with all the risks that delimitation
entailed.
keywords: Bengali, Braj Bhasha, Hindi, literature, Mahavir Prasad
Dwivedi, modernisation, nation, public sphere, sahitya, Sarasvati,
Urdu
The Linguistic Landscape of Northern India
Language and literature, by the turn of the twentieth century, had become two of
the most politicised benchmarks of modern national identity in colonial North
India. The English East India Company’s decree in 1837 to replace Persian as
the language of the courts and administration with English at the higher levels
and regional vernaculars at the lower levels had sparked considerable debate and
political mobilisation over the question of an ‘official’ vernacular in regions such as
the Northwest Provinces and Awadh, where more than one language and script was