Psychological Medicine, 1980,10, 125-132
Printed in Great Britain
Psychiatric screening on a neurological ward
J. RAYMOND DEPAULO,
1
MARSHAL F. FOLSTEIN AND BARRY GORDON
From the Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences and the Department of Neurology,
Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
SYNOPSIS Two psychiatric screening instruments, the Mini-Mental State (MMS), a test for
cognitive disturbance, and the General Health Questionnaire (GHQ), were administered to 197
neurological in-patients. The results suggest a high rate of psychiatric disturbance. The highest rate
of cognitive disturbance detected by the MMS was found in patients with Parkinson's disease. The
highest rates of emotional disturbance indicated by GHQ scores were found in patients with myas-
thenia gravis and multiple sclerosis. MMS scores but not GHQ scores were related to standard
tests of cognition, the diagnosis of cerebral pathology, and CAT scan abnormality. The results also
demonstrate that the GHQ does not adequately detect patients with cognitive impairment. It is
concluded that in populations at high risk for cognitive impairment a tandem screening procedure
utilizing tests for both cognitive and emotional disorders is needed.
INTRODUCTION
Medically ill patients frequently suffer from
psychiatric disorders. New methods for psy-
chiatric screening permit studies of psychiatric
morbidity in large populations (Goldberg, 1972;
Goldberg et al. 1976; Derogatis et al. 1976),
including medically ill patients unable to co-
operate with more detailed methods of testing.
Several previous screening surveys of medically
ill populations have been limited to screening
for emotional disturbances (Maguire et al. 1974;
Eastwood & Trevelyan, 1972). Since medically
ill patients suffer high rates of cognitive defects
(Jacobs et al. 1977; Knights & Folstein, 1977),
psychiatric screening instruments which detect
cognitive defects as well as those which detect
depression and anxiety are needed to define the
rate of psychiatric morbidity in a medical setting.
Whether or not screening tests for emotional
symptoms also detect patients with cognitive
defects in medical or neurological populations is
unknown.
The special problem of psychiatric morbidity
in neurological patients has received the atten-
tion of the American Board of Psychiatry and
Neurology (Trufant & Landau, 1975) and recent
British and American publications (Lishman,
1
Address for correspondence: Dr J. Raymond DePaulo,
Department of Psychiatry, Baltimore City Hospital, Balti-
more, Maryland 21224, USA.
125
0033-2917/80/2828-4940 $01.00 ©1980 Cambridge University Press
1978; Benson & Blumer, 1975). However, we
know from an earlier study that psychiatric
disorders are not always clinically recognized
by neurologists and, hence, do not always
receive adequate diagnosis and treatment
(DePaulo & Folstein, 1978). Determining the
relative risk of psychiatric morbidity in patients
with a variety of neurological disorders would
allow high-risk neurological conditions to be
identified and, thus, increase the alerted physi-
cian's detection of psychiatric morbidity in
patients with these disorders. In addition, the
identification of high-risk groups in a neurological
setting would help to establish the association of
psychopathology with particular neurological
disorders, since associations reported from psy-
chiatric facilities are flawed by the bias of
ascertainment.
In this study on a neurological ward we
evaluated the clinical utility and efficiency of a
tandem screening procedure with two psychiatric
screening instruments: the Mini-Mental State
Examination (MMS) for cognitive disorder and
the General Health Questionnaire (GHQ) for
emotional disorder. One hundred and ninety-seven
patients in a neurological setting were tested for
the presence of cognitive or emotional disturb-
ance, and those diagnostic groups which were
detected most frequently by the screening tests
were identified.