Detection of Chlorinated Hydrocarbons in Aqueous
Surfactant Solutions by Near-IR Raman Spectroscopy
XUELONG SHI, STEPHEN J. PARUS, KURT D. PENNELL, and MICHAEL D. MORRIS*
Department of Chemistry (X.S., S.J.P., M.D.M.) and Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering (K.D.P.), University of
Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan 48109-1055
Near-IR Raman spectroscopy is used to detect chlorinated hydrocarbons
under sorfactant-enhanced soluhilization conditions. The Raman bands
of tetrachloroethylene (PCE) and 1,2-dichlorobenzene (DCB) in micelle
solutions could be observed in the presence of humie acid when a 784-
nm diode laser was used. With 532- or 632.8-nm excitation, humic acid
fluorescence obscured the Raman signals. For quantification, the inte-
grated area of the carbon-chlorine stretch mode (PCE) or the phenyl
ring-breathing mode (DCB) was used. Test results for samples with
unknown concentrations based on linear calibration curves were in agree-
ment with results from an accepted gas chromatography method. De-
tection limits were calculated to be 240 ppm for tetrachloroethylene and
500 ppm for 1,2-dichlorobenzene. Our study has shown the feasibility
of this technique for field applications.
Index Headings: Raman spectroscopy; Diode laser; Chlorinated hydro-
carbons; Surfactant solutions; Environmental analysis.
INTRODUCTION
The migration and fate of nonaqueous-phase liquid
(NAPL) organic contaminants in the subsurface have been
the subject of intensive investigation in recent years.~ Of
particular concern are sites contaminated with one class
of nonaqueous-phase liquid organic contaminants, chlo-
rinated solvents, which, because of their high densities
and low viscosities, are not typically confined to the un-
saturated ground-water zone. 2
To prevent further migration of these contaminants,
and to allow safe use of already contaminated areas, con-
taminated sites require immediate remedial action. One
promising approach is surfactant-enhanced aquifer re-
mediation (SEAR). 3-6 This technique is based on the am-
phipathic property of the surfactant and can be carried
out by injecting aqueous surfactant solutions into con-
taminated areas. These solutions contain surfactant con-
centrations sufficient to cause the formation of micelles,
which are responsible for the enhanced solubilization of
organic liquids in aqueous phase. The successful field
implementation of this remediation technique requires
an accurate and portable analytical tool to assist in as-
sessment of NAPL recovery efficiency and to identify
NAPL compositions and locations.
Analytical techniques currently available for determi-
nation of organic concentrations in surfactant/organic
mixtures are not well suited for in situ or on site mea-
surements. Gas chromatography has excellent detection
limits but usually requires relatively long instrument time
and sample preparation steps. 7,8 Infrared absorption mea-
surement is difficult or impossible in aqueous systems
because of strong water background absorption. 9
Received 28 December 1994; accepted 20 April 1995.
* Author to whom correspondence should be sent.
Raman spectroscopy, on the other hand, appears quite
promising for detecting those organics because they are
strong Raman scatterers and water is a weak Raman scat-
terer. ~° Sampling systems for Raman spectroscopy are
generally simpler than those needed for infrared spec-
troscopy. Most importantly for field applications, in the
visible or near-infrared regions, glass containers and glass
optics can be used in Raman spectroscopy instead of
fragile and expensive crystal optics used in infrared ab-
sorption spectroscopy.
The solubilities of chlorinated hydrocarbons in pure
water are too low (150 ppm for tetrachloroethylene, for
example) for normal Raman spectroscopy, and surface-
enhanced Raman spectroscopy is often used for direct
detection. ~,~2 However, because of the enhanced solu-
bilities of organics in surfactant solutions, efficient re-
mediation procedures can concentrate the compounds to
such concentration levels that normal Raman spectros-
copy is adequate to detect those organics. For monitoring
remediation processes, low detection limits are less im-
portant than the existence of compact, reliable field-de-
ployable instrumentation.
The simplicity and portability of modern Raman in-
strumentation, along with the minimal sample prepara-
tion requirements, make the technique attractive. But
practical applications of the technique under surfactant-
enhanced solubilization conditions will be possible only
if the surfactant and humic acid do not give strong flu-
orescence background and interfere with the analyses. We
have investigated the fluorescence background from sur-
factant and humic acid using different excitation sources
(532-nm Nd:YAG, 632.8-nm He-Ne, and 784-nm diode
laser). It was found that, in the presence of humic acid,
the Raman signals of chlorinated hydrocarbons can be
observed with 784-nm diode laser excitation, but they
are obscured in the large fluorescence background with
visible laser excitation. In addition, calibration and quan-
tification procedures have been developed, and the results
of Raman spectroscopic measurements have been veri-
fied by comparison with those from accepted analytical
techniques.
EXPERIMENTAL
Apparatus. Raman spectra were obtained with locally
constructed systems. The excitation source was a diode
pumped Nd:YAG operated at 532 nm (Adlas, Stow, MA),
a 632.8-nm He-Ne (MWK Industries, Corona, CA) or a
784-nm semiconductor diode (Model 5412-H 1, Spectra
Diode Labs, San Jose, CA). In each case, the laser power
at the sample was about 25 roW. Small glass containers
were used to hold the samples. Excitation and back-scat-
1146 Volume 49, Number 8, 1 9 9 5 0003-702S/95/4908-114652.00/0 APPLIED SPECTROSCOPY
© 1995 Society for Applied Spectroscopy