RESEARCH POSTER PRESENTATION DESIGN © 2012
www.PosterPresentations.com
• Identify the factors controlling
arsenic concentrations in soil and
surface waters
Objective
The sample sites are located within the Ganges
Delta System in the Bengal Basin. They are
north of the Sundarbans National Park, the
largest mangrove forest in the world. This
region experiences a tropical, biseasonal
climate. Samples were collected in May (dry
season) and November (wet season). Sample
types included Rice Paddy (RP), Tidal Channel
(TC), Aquaculture (A), Rainwater, Tubewell
(TW), Sundarbans mangrove forest (SS), and
Pond Sand Filter (PSF).
Results
Conclusions
• Water: Nearly all tubewell samples have As > WHO guideline of 0.01 mg/L, while
some rice paddy water samples in May exceed the guideline because some fields are
irrigated with tubewell water.
• Rice paddy water: Arsenic increases with increasing soil sulfur and decreasing pH,
suggesting that As is liberated by sulfide dissolution. Arsenic in rice paddy water also
decreases from month 5 to 11 due to dilution during the monsoon.
• Rice paddy soil extract: Arsenic increases with extract DOC and S concentrations and
decreases with increasing S in soil, suggesting that sulfide dissolution transfers As to
soil porewaters, and that As is complexed with DOC in the extract solution. No
correlation with P or Fe is observed, indicating that competitive adsorption with
PO
4
3-
on ferric oxyhydroxides does not control As solubility.
• Rice paddy bulk soil: Arsenic is positively correlated with As concentration in
irrigation water, suggesting that As from irrigation water is added to the soil. As pH
increases from 7 to 8, K
D
(soil/extract) increases. This is consistent with the observed
positive correlation between irrigation water pH and bulk soil As concentration.
• Waterlogging of rice paddy soils leads to reducing conditions, the absence of ferric
oxyhydroxides that could sorb As, and the presence of sulfides that incorporate As.
• Arsenic bioavailability could be decreased through soil aeration (draining and tilling)
and by avoiding the use of groundwater for rice paddy irrigation.
Acknowledgements
• Office of Naval Research Grant # N00014-11-1-0683, National Science Foundation grant OCE-1600319
• Rossane Delapp (Vanderbilt University), Kushal Roy, Md. Rezaul Karim and Farjana Akhter (Khulna
University), Saddam Hossain (Dhaka University), Basu Kumar (Dhaka University), Chelsea Peters
(Vanderbilt University)
John C. Ayers and Brooke Patton
Dept. of Earth & Environmental Sciences, Vanderbilt University, Nashville, TN, USA
Analysis of Factors Influencing Soil and Water Arsenic Concentration in
Southwest Bangladesh
Abstract
Soil samples (n = 45) and water samples (n = 111) were collected in the coastal zone of SW
Bangladesh in wet (November) and dry (May) seasons in 2016 to identify the factors influencing
soil arsenic concentrations. Soils are entisols formed from recently deposited, predominantly
silt-sized sediments with low carbon concentrations typical of the local mangrove forests.
Arsenic concentrations in bulk soil are higher in November than in May and vary little between
sites. Arsenic concentrations in deionized H2O extracts are ~2 orders of magnitude lower,
indicating only ~1% of As is soluble. Water samples show that As concentrations are highest in
groundwater from tubewells. Bulk soil As is positively correlated with As concentration in
irrigation water, suggesting that As from irrigation water is added to the soil. Unlike other water
types, As in rice paddy water is much higher in the wet season, consistent with some fields
being irrigated with tubewell water. Arsenic in rice paddy water increases by soil sulfide
dissolution, and decreases by dilution during the monsoon. Water soluble As in rice paddy soils
is positively correlated with S and DOC concentrations in rice paddy soil extracts due to sulfide
dissolution and complexation with DOC. Thus, waterlogging of rice paddy soils leads to reducing
conditions, the absence of ferric oxyhydroxides that could sorb As, and the presence of sulfides
that incorporate As. As soil pH increases from 7 to 8, K
D
(soil/extract) increases, consistent with
the observed positive correlation between irrigation water pH and bulk soil As concentration.
Arsenic bioavailability could be decreased through soil aeration (draining and tilling) and by
avoiding the use of groundwater for rice paddy irrigation.
Fig. 3: Bulk soil
As concent-
rations are
highest at site
B3, but overlap
substantially
between sites,
so all sites are
lumped
together.
Figure 3.
Results (continued)
Methods
• Soil and water samples were
collected in May and
November 2016 (Figs. 1 and
2).
• Bulk soil samples (fused in
LiBO
2
, then dissolved in
dilute HNO
3
) and soil
extracts (1:5 soil: deionized
water) were analyzed using
ICP-OES, ICP-MS, IC, and a
TOC analyzer.
Fig. 2: Examples of study area’s biseasonal climate. Top:
November 2016. Bottom: May 2016.
Background
Site
Avg. Soluble
As in RP Soil
(ppm)
Avg. As in
RP Bulk
Soil (ppm)
% soluble
B2 0.01 0.97 1%
B3 0.03 2.25 1%
B8 0.04 1.36 3%
B9 0.02 2.17 1%
P32 0.02 1.57 1%
Fig. 4: Soil types: RP = Rice Paddy, DRP = Dry Rice Paddy, SS = Sundarbans, TC = Tidal Channel.
Bulk soil As concentrations don’t vary significantly by soil type or season. As in soil extracts
also show little variation, except are higher in May TC samples. Rice paddy As concentrations
are much higher in bulk soil than in soil extracts: ~ 1% of soil As is water soluble (Table 1).
Fig. 5: Boxplot of As concentrations in water samples. Type abbreviations the same as for soils,
plus A = Aquaculture (brine shrimp pond), PSF = Pond Sand Filter, TW = Tubewell. Reference
lines: WHO = World Health Organization guideline, MDL = Method Detection Limit.
1. Arsenic in RP water: logC
As
water
= 0.83*logC
S
bulksoil
-0.39*pH
water
– 0.20*Monthnum + 0.68, n
= 9, adj. r
2
= 0.89.
2. Arsenic in RP soil extracts: logC
As
soilextract
= 0.74*logC
DOC
soilextract
– 0.23*logC
S
bulksoil
+
0.15*logC
S
soilextract
-3.15, n = 11, adj. r
2
= 0.69.
3. Arsenic in RP bulk soil: C
As
bulksoil
= 13.3*C
As
irrwater
+ 1.89*pH
irrwater
+ 10.6, n = 5, adj. r
2
= 0.998
Fig. 6: As concentrations in bulk soil
and DI water extract are not
correlated, indicating partitioning
equilibrium is not achieved. However,
K
D
As(bulk soil/extract) values seem
to increase from pH 7 to 8.
Table 1
Given that As concentrations do
not seem to depend on one
variable, we performed multiple
linear regression to identify the
factors controlling As in rice
paddies:
P32
SS
(Sundarbans)
Fig. 1: Map of sample locations. Red circles
represent only May 2016 sites. Purple
circles were added in November 2016.
ESSOAr | https://doi.org/10.1002/essoar.9c1e066b380e79b8.f7e7c19cad064cd7.1 | CC_BY_NC_4.0 | First posted online: Sun, 11 Mar 2018 14:55:54 | This content has not been peer reviewed.