Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Ecological Economics
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/ecolecon
The Economy-Wide Value-at-Risk from the Exposure of Natural Capital to
ClimateChangeandExtremeNaturalEvents:TheCaseofWindDamageand
Forest Recreational Services in New Zealand
Juan J. Monge
a,
⁎
, Garry W. McDonald
b
a
Market Economics Ltd, Digital Basecamp, 1132 Hinemoa Street, Rotorua 3010, New Zealand
b
Market Economics Ltd, Level 5, 507 Lake Road, Takapuna 0740, Auckland, New Zealand
ARTICLEINFO
Keywords:
Extreme natural events
Natural capital
Ecosystem services
Input-Output inoperability
Probabilistic risk assessment
Value at risk
Climate change
ABSTRACT
The long-term management of natural capital is essential for the stable and resilient flow of ecosystem services
for future generations facing climatic uncertainty. Understanding its resilience to extreme natural events, using
biological principles, and integrating them into more holistic systems-wide modelling techniques is crucial to
evaluate and design the wider economic impacts from alternative management interventions. Here we devel-
oped a probabilistic and system-wide bio-economic model to measure extreme economic impacts from natural
eventsusingthefinancialconceptofValueatRisk.Wehaveappliedthenewextremeeconomicimpactmetricto
measure the economy-wide impact from the disruption of mountain-biking recreational services in the
Whakarewarewa peri-urban forest in Rotorua, New Zealand from a potential windthrow event. We identified
thatextremenaturalevents,suchaswindthrows,couldexertasubstantialimpactontheurbanforest-dependent
regional economy. This impact could potentially be intensified by the CO
2
forest fertilization effects predicted
under future climate scenarios and by adopting low-intensity silvicultural regimes currently rewarded by na-
tionalclimatechangemitigationpolicies.Someoftheinsightsfromthisstudycouldbetheprecursorstodevelop
robust adaptation strategies using robust decision-making techniques considering inclusive environmental-
economic accounting frameworks.
1. Introduction
The long-term management of natural capital is essential for the
stable and resilient flow of ecosystem services for future generations
facing evolving socio-economic and climatic uncertainty. Under the
current economic system, solely rewarding the short-term provision of
marketedcommoditiesandecosystemservicesisnotenoughasitmight
result in the depletion of natural capital stocks in the long run. Hence,
understanding the role of natural capital, and its interactions with the
other four types of capital (i.e. manufactured, financial, social and
human), is key to inform decision- and policy-makers in charge of de-
signing reward mechanisms to incentivise long-term stewardship
(Fenichel et al., 2016; Guerry et al., 2015).
Forest ecosystems are some of the most valuable terrestrial ecosys-
tems in the world generating services valued at approximately $25
billion/year (Costanzaetal.,2014).
1
These valuable ecosystem services
depend on the interaction between the natural capital within the forest
ecosystems and other types of capital to support human well-being. For
example, recreational ecosystem services such as mountain biking de-
pend on natural capital in the form of forests, social capital in the form
of a symbiotic public-private governance structure, improve human
capital in the form of human health, and affect regional economies
sustained by manufactured capital backed by financial capital.
Within the wider forest ecosystem, urban forests are also highly
valuable natural capital when considering the concentration of people
benefiting from their ecosystem services - approximately 55% of the
world's population generating more than 80% of global Gross Domestic
Product (GDP) (United Nations, 2018; Dobbs et al., 2011; Willis and
Petrokofsky, 2017). For example, the median annual benefit in nine
megacities, across five continents and biomes, was estimated to be
approximately $781 million from urban forests reducing air pollution,
avoiding processed stormwater, saving building energy and
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecolecon.2020.106747
Received 11 February 2020; Received in revised form 15 April 2020; Accepted 2 June 2020
⁎
Corresponding author.
E-mail addresses: juan@me.co.nz (J.J. Monge), garry@me.co.nz (G.W. McDonald).
1
$ will represent New Zealand Dollars throughout the article. The going exchange rate at the moment of the development of the article was NZ$1.57/US$. Hence
the original value assigned for forest ecosystem services was approximately US$16 billion/year.
Ecological Economics 176 (2020) 106747
0921-8009/ © 2020 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
T