Human Reproduction vol.10 no.5 pp.1152-1155, 1995
Pregnancies after microsurgical correction of partial
epididymal and vasal obstruction
R.Hauser
1
-
2
'
3
, P.D.Temple-Smith
2
, GJ.Southwick
2
,
J.McFarlane
1
and D.M.de Kretser
1
'institute of Reproduction and Development and
2
Male Infertility
Microsurgery Research Programme, Department of Anatomy,
Monash University, Clayton, Victoria 3168, Australia
3
To whom correspondence should be addressed at: 16 Alumim
Street, Tel Aviv 69690, Israel
A group of 16 infertile patients suspected of having a
partial epididymal obstruction on the basis of severe oligo-
zoospermia, normal-sized testes and a normal serum
follicle-stimulating hormone, underwent scrotal explora-
tion. Evidence of partial obstruction of the epididymis was
found in 13 cases and of the vas deferens in one case,
and was supported by finding normal spermatogenesis on
testicular biopsy. Vasoepididymostomy or vasovasostomy
were performed, resulting in a significant improvement of
semen analysis in 50% of cases and in six pregnancies in two
patients. The diagnosis of partial epididymal obstruction
should be considered when the above criteria are met. If
pregnancies do not result when intracytoplasmic sperm
injection (ICSI) is used with the ejaculated spermatozoa,
a testicular biopsy followed by a microsurgical by-pass
procedure should be considered whenever normal
spermatogenesis is diagnosed. In all cases, the epididymal
spermatozoa should be aspirated during the operation
and either used immediately for insemination or stored
frozen. The remarkable results of the new artificial repro-
duction technologies and in particular ICSI, question the
indication for microsurgical correction in cases of partial
epididymal obstruction.
Key words: epididymis/infertility/microsurgery/oligozoospermia/
vasoepididymostomy
Introduction
Extremely severe oligozoospermia (<1X1O
6
total sperm
count/ml) is a well recognized cause of male infertility and
has a poor prognosis. It has been suggested that partial
obstruction of the epididymis is a cause of this state in some
patients; previous studies claimed that 10-25% of all severe
oligozoospermic patients had a partial obstruction (Silber and
Rodriguez-Rigau, 1981; Schoysman, 1988). The presence of
severe oligozoospermia accompanied by vigorous spermato-
genesis, as revealed by a testicular biopsy, was considered as an
indication of a partial obstruction to sperm outflow, which
1152
might be reversed by microsurgical procedures (Silber and
Rodriguez-Rigau, 1981; Schoysman, 1988).
We report on a series of 16 infertile patients with extremely
severe oligozoospermia in whom testicular biopsies showed
spermatogenesis ranging from normal to severe hypospermato-
genesis and who underwent testicular exploration and micro-
surgical by-pass procedures. The indications for such procedures
in the face of the new assisted reproductive technologies
currently available are discussed in the light of these results.
Materials and methods
Patients
The outcome of 16 male patients aged 25—48 years (mean
32.0 ± 5.8 SD) with extremely severe oligozoospermia and
infertility, who were referred to the andrology microsurgical
clinic for investigation, was retrospectively analysed. Of this
group, 15 had primary infertility lasting 1-10 years and one had
secondary infertility of 11 years duration with a documented
episode of epididymitis 5 years earlier. Five patients had
attempted in-vitro fertilization (IVF) procedures in the past
but the rest had been rejected for IVF due to poor semen
characteristics. All men had a physical examination with special
emphasis on male secondary sexual characteristics, testicular
volume and possible congenital absence of parts of the sperm
transport system. Eight of the patients reported symptoms or
findings suggestive of the incidence of genital infections in the
past (epididymitis, urethritis, etc.).
Semen analyses and antisperm antibody assessment
Several semen analyses over a period of up to 10 years were
obtained in each patient and were repeated before the operation
to validate the diagnosis.
Antisperm antibody assessment in serum and seminal plasma
were performed in all patients using an indirect immunobead
test (IIBT) for immunoglobulin (Ig) G and IgA (Bio-Rad
Laboratories, Richmond, CA, USA). Positive results were
considered when 50% of the spermatozoa bound immuno-
beads, for both serum and seminal plasma tests.
Hormone assays
Serum follicle-stimulating hormone (FSH) and luteinizing
hormone (LH) were measured in all patients by specific radio-
immunoassays employing the World Health Organization inter-
national reference standards (69/104 and 78/549). The
normal range for FSH in males was 0.9-7.0 mlU/ml and the
normal range for LH was 0.9-13.0 mlU/ml. Serum
© Oxford University Press