European Journal of
POLITICAL
European Journal of Political Economy ECONOMY
Vol. 12 (1996) 723-727 ELSEVIER
The voting mechanism and market allocation:
A note
Jean J. Gabszewicz *, Tanguy Van Ypersele
CORE, Catholic University of Louoain, 34 Voie du Roman Pays, 1348 Louoain-la-Neuve, Belgium
Received 15 March 1995; revised 15 August 1995; accepted 15 September1995
Abstract
An example is provided identifying a new case of inefficiency arising from the interplay
between the political and market mechanisms.
Keywords: Political economy
1. Votes on political issues having economic implications are increasingly
observed in modern democracies. The provision of public goods, the choice of
fiscal, environmental or trade policies, social protection are only a few examples
among the plethora of economic issues falling into the domain of modern electoral
competition. Generally, the efficiency aspects of public decision-making concern-
ing such issues are evaluated as if these issues were decided by a benevolent
dictator maximizing social welfare. An interesting question is whether the political
mechanism of majority voting on alternative proposals leads spontaneously to the
optimal outcome which would be chosen under benevolent dictatorship.
Several examples exist in the literature pointing out that the equilibrium
strategies of two candidates competing to win an election do not necessarily
provide an economically efficient outcome. For instance, there has been a consid-
erable literature about the deadweight costs incurred as a consequence of tariff
protection reflecting maximization of political support (see Hillman, 1989; Mayer,
1984). Another example is related to the provision of a public good (Shepsle and
* Corresponding author
0176-2680/96/$15.00 Copyright © 1996 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
PII SO176-2680(96)00026-2