D. Harris (Ed.): Engin. Psychol. and Cog. Ergonomics, HCII 2011, LNAI 6781, pp. 225–232, 2011.
© Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2011
Information Searching on the Web: The Cognitive
Difficulties Experienced by Older Users in Modifying
Unsuccessful Information Searches
Aline Chevalier
1
, Aurélie Dommes
2
, and Jean-Claude Marquié
1
1
Laboratoire CLLE-LTC (UMR 5263, CNRS, Université de Toulouse, EPHE), Maison De
la Recherche, 5 Allées Machado, 31058 Toulouse Cedex 9, France
2
IFSTTAR, French institute of science and technology for transport, development and
networks. 25 allée des Marronniers, 78 000 Versailles-Cedex, France
{aline.chevalier,marquie}@univ-tlse2.fr,
aurelie.dommes@ifsttar.fr
Abstract. The present study addressed age-related differences in performances
and strategies developed by web users while searching for information. Ten
older and 10 younger adults had to search for information with Google and to
answer 9 questions varying in complexity: from simple ones (participants
needed to use keywords provided in the questions) to impossible ones (no
answer existed). The results showed that older participants had lower
performances than younger ones; age-related differences were more particularly
marked as the question complexity increased. Regression analyses showed that
processing speed and cognitive flexibility accounted for a large part of the
variance in performances. The younger and older participants also differed in
the strategies they developed while searching for information. The older
participants tended to focus on the evaluation of the results provided by Google.
In contrast, the younger participants tended to plan and regulate their activity,
this last strategy provided better performances.
Keywords: Information searching; aging; question complexity; cognitive
abilities; strategies.
1 Introduction
The information searching (IS) activity can be considered as problem-solving and
decision-making activities whereby the problem-solver’s knowledge and other mental
representations are manipulated in order to achieve a goal. More precisely, according
to Sharit, Hernandez, Czaja and Pirolli [11], the information problem-solving process
is divided into the three following sub-processes:
• The representation of the problem to be solved. The problem statement is
internalized in order to build up a mental representation of the information
elements to be searched.
• The planning. A method for coming up with a solution is elaborated. It often
requires dividing the problem into sub-goals.
• The execution. The operations that were elaborated during the planning
process are carried out.