International Journal of Mechanical & Mechatronics Engineering IJMME-IJENS Vol: 11 No: 05 19
113805-9494 IJMME-IJENS © October 2011 IJENS
I J E N S
Hydraulic Field Test RIG and Evaluating Plant
Oil Performance
WB. Wan Nik
1*
, F. Zulkifli
1
, A. Ahmad
1
, O. Sulaiman
1
, S. Syahrullail
2
1
Department of Maritime Technology, Universiti Malaysia Terengganu, 21030 Terengganu, Malaysia
2
Faculty of Mechanical Engineering, Universiti Teknologi Malaysia, 81300 Johor, Malaysia
*
niksani@umt.edu.my
Abstract - Development of environmental friendly hydraulic
fluid has a major influence in ecologically benign environment.
This future type of oil should be non-toxic, biodegradable and
ecological benign. Subsequently, it becomes crucial to
recognize the sustainability of such oil in maintaining a high
system performance which resulting in tremendous
contribution towards machinery technology. Furthermore, the
development of methods to evaluate the actual performance of
hydraulic fluid has been of great interest. In this project a
hydraulic test rig which incorporates LabView data acquisition
system (DAQ) was built to conduct endurance test where it can
be operated for up to 280 bar, running continuously with
several safety features. The rig was used to test the oil and
other stringent parameters, running for nearly 10000 hours at
the temperature of 70 ºC under constant pressure of 70 bar
and pump speed of 40 Hz. Major factors in the decrease of
mechanical efficiency are thermal heat, friction, aging
behaviour and contamination of the plant oil. Explained in this
paper are the features of the hydraulic system built to evaluate
the performance of plant oils, accompanied by some results for
evaluating the suitability of the usage of plant oil as hydraulic
fluid.
Index Term-- hydraulic fluid, mechanical efficiency, plant oil,
volumetric efficiency
I. INTRODUCTION
Petroleum oil is a non-renewable energy resource that
has been used in wide range of important applications which
include transportations and power generations. Despite of its
popular use, there are efforts to produce diesel oil from the
used engine oil [1], aiming to use non-petroleum oil to fuel
automobiles. Majority of the researchers concentrated on the
use of plant oil which commonly known as biodiesel. Some
examples in the study include soy, rapeseed, palm and corn
oil. Less known plants are also researched such the use of
jatropha oil as an alternative fuel in diesel engine [2].
Furthermore, the research on plant oil is not limited to its
use as an energy resource where it has been researched to be
an alternative for traditional lubricant and hydraulic fluid, i.e.
bio-lubricant and bio-hydraulic fluid.
As there are evidences over the growing environmental
concerns in some regions over the use of mineral-based
hydraulic fluid, the plant-based hydraulic fluid is able to
serve as an alternative solution to the mineral-based oil.
Besides of being environmentally friendly, there are several
factors that show the attractiveness of plant-based hydraulic
fluid:
i. Plentiful supply and relatively low cost.
ii. Some plant oils offer excellent lubricating
properties [3], e.g. mild antiwear/extreme-pressure.
performance.
iii. No adverse effects on unit performance
characteristics [4].
However, it is well known that plant oils have poor low-
temperature fluidity and rapid oxidation at elevated
temperatures [5-7]. In addition, plant oils are limited to their
naturally inherent viscosity (kinematic viscosity at 40 ºC of
30-45 cSt depending on oil type) [4]. Furthermore, plant oils
also show low static friction coefficients not depending on
the kinds of wet friction materials. Since hydraulic motors
of a hydraulic excavator contain wet parking brakes, the
most commercially available plant oils cannot provide
enough brake torque capacity to park safely. Several other
disadvantages of plant-based hydraulic fluid include:
i. Rarely capable of providing adequate long-term
performance.
ii. Low oxidation resistance (can be enhanced by
addition of synthetic ester).
iii. Those with capable of meeting required
temperature and oxidation performance is at a very
premium price.
Judging on the disadvantages of the plant-based
hydraulic fluid and the standard requirements that need to be
fulfilled, it is vital to determine the performance of the oil in
a real hydraulic system. In this work, the effects from the
oil degradation towards the hydraulic system efficiencies are
investigated. Some of the factors, such as temperature and
friction, which contribute to the degradation process, are
studied by varying the pump speed and loading charge of
the operation. Data obtained from the tests are used to
determine the effects of speed, pressure and temperature
towards the system’s volumetric, mechanical and overall
efficiencies. In addition, studies on the oil viscosity and its
acid value provided supporting data to the results obtained.
The authors have tested the physical and chemical
performance of various plant oils. The authors managed to
improve the thermal and oxidation properties of the plant
oils [5]. The lubrication and rheological properties of the oil
have also been evaluated [7]. This is to complement the
tribological investigation done in the United States and
Europe [8, 9]. These tribological results are very important
in order to use plant oils as other industrial fluid [10].
There are many off-the-shelf test rigs to test biodiesel
running on engine that include several bench tester to test
hydraulic fluid, such as to test corrosivity, viscosity,