Int. J Sup. Chain. Mgt Vol. 8, No. 6, December 2019
595
Making Dual Procurement and Supply Chain
Operations: Cases in the Indonesian Higher
Education
Agus Sunarya Sulaeman
1
, Budi Waluyo
2
, Hapzi Ali
3*
1
Department of Financial Management, Polytechnic of State Finance STAN, Jakarta, Indonesia.
2
School of Business, University of Leicester, Leicester, United Kingdom
3
Department of Post Graduate Program, Univeristas Mercu Buana (UMB) Jakarta, Indonesia
my.paper03@gmail.com
Abstract— A high performing procurement and
supply chain function is vital to the success of running
a safe, productive and efficient educational
organisation, and can make a significant contribution
to both financial and operational performance Higher
education institutions in Indonesia have experienced
significant changes since the introduction of the semi-
autonomous agency model. In the context of
procurement, these agencies adopt both Government
Procurement Procedure issued by the central
government for all government institutions and
Special Procurement Procedure prepared by the
agency. Consequently, the agencies have to implement
two different procurement procedures in accordance
with each procedure. This study deeply looks at the
implementation of the dual procurement procedures
at a micro level in the context of gentrification. This
research focuses on examining the use of dual
procurement procedures in supporting through an
exploration of the experiences of higher education in
Indonesia. A central feature of procurement in the
Indonesian higher education is unnecessary dual
procedures. Higher education institutions have
experienced many constraints in developing and
implementing dual procurement procedures. The
internal factors include risk, human resources,
quality, and organizational structure, while external
factors consist of the audit, political pressure, and
regulation.
Keywords— agencification, autonomous agency, higher
education, procurement and supply chain strategy
1. Introduction
Procurement teams are good neighbors with their
counterparts in supply chain management. The
public sector adds a layer of complexity due to the
nature of service delivery. In particular, higher
education is both a key public service provider and
consumer with expertise in teaching and research.
Meanwhile, the financial inflexibility encourages
the civil service organization to become
autonomous, so called ‘agency’ or quasi
autonomous non-governmental bodies – quangos
[1-15].
The number and the importance of autonomous
agency have expanded in almost all countries and
following the global trend, the Indonesian
administration has extensively implemented the
agency model since 2005 [4, 16-20]; [21-23].
Agency is identified as a set of institutions, or
structures for delivering public services proposed
by government actors [5] and has some autonomy
from their respective ministry in policy decision
making and over personnel, financial and
managerial matters [6] including business plan and
budget [4], accounting system [4], costing system
[7] and organization structure [8]. Many have
claimed the encouraging effects of agencification
in which agencies would be more professional,
their management would be more business-like,
and they would offer higher quality services
compared to traditional government bureaucracy
Osborne and [9]; [10] as they have a minimum
standard of service delivery [7]. Besides better
output quality, agencies are expected to be more
efficient public service providers [10]; [19].
Indonesian public service agencies beginning to
work with the bureaucratic approach are driven to
implement the business-like approach by adopting
new financial management [4]. Since 2005 the
Indonesian government has been implementing
financial management model of Public Service
Agency (Badan Layanan Umum, BLU) for the
particular government institution which is primarily
responsible for providing public services [4].
Agencification has been a major approach under
the Yudhoyono administration [11]; [17]; [18]. In
the period 2005 to 2014, there were 689 agencies
established in Indonesia consisting of 150 central
agencies and 539 local agencies. (see Figure 1).
______________________________________________________________
International Journal of Supply Chain Management
IJSCM, ISSN: 2050-7399 (Online), 2051-3771 (Print)
Copyright © ExcelingTech Pub, UK (http://excelingtech.co.uk/)