Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Sustainable Energy Technologies and Assessments
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/seta
Design of a bus shelter based on green energy technologies for extreme
weather conditions in Nur-Sultan, Kazakhstan
Arailym Alikhanova, Aldiyar Kakimzhan, Anuarbek Mukhanov, Luis Rojas-Solórzano
⁎
School of Engineering, Nazarbayev University, 53 Kabanbay batyr Ave., Nur-Sultan city 010000, Kazakhstan
ARTICLE INFO
Keywords:
Nur-Sultan
Bus shelter
Design
Geothermal energy
Green energy
ABSTRACT
Green energy technologies in combination with conventional technologies can result in viable solutions in many
applications within the fundamental areas of the economy, including the transportation segment. This sector has
recently experienced rapid development in Nur-Sultan, capital of the Republic of Kazakhstan and one of the
popular projects in the city is the construction of “warm” bus shelters. Nevertheless, current bus shelters have
insufficient space for passengers and use grid electricity, which is mostly generated in heavily polluting coal-
fired power plants. Thus, this paper proposes the modernization of the shelter at “Cardiac Surgery Center” bus
stop by using an optimal combination of clean and conventional energy sources. The technical and financial
viability analyses were performed using RETScreen 4 and HOMER LEGACY state-of-the-art software platforms,
which permitted to model the energetic system and determine its technical and economic viability within given
financial and market conditions. Simulations demonstrated that including a geothermal heat pump unit in the
system would be a profitable solution with relatively short payback period. However, possible combinations of
grid electricity with wind and solar energy technologies resulted in higher net present cost than the conventional
only-grid connected system.
Introduction
Renewable energy sources such as solar, wind, marine, hydropower,
geothermal, and biomass have recently gained a lot of attention as al-
ternatives for electricity generation. Overall, they contribute to 15–20%
of the worldwide energy demand. This figure is expected to increase to
30% by 2020 and to 50% in 2050 [15]. Likewise, Republic of Ka-
zakhstan is also concerned with the development of the renewable
energy sector. This is evident from the main theme of EXPO-2017 AS-
TANA, which is development of “green energy” [8]. In addition, the
transportation sector has been one of the fastest developing segments in
Nur-Sultan, the capital city of Kazakhstan, since the establishment of
“Astana Transportation Authority” in 2011.
The green shelter challenge
One of the popular projects in this sector is the construction of
“warm” bus shelters. However, there are still several problems like the
lack of space in the bus shelter for passengers and the use of grid power.
In addition, transition to renewable energy sources would be a logical
next step within the framework of EXPO-2017. Therefore, our paper
proposes modernization of the bus shelter at “Cardiac Surgery Center”
bus stop (in front of “Asia Park” shopping mall) with clean energy
sources, particularly solar and wind for electricity supply, and geo-
thermal unit for heat generation. Nevertheless, the viability must be
firstly assessed through the simulation of multiple technologies and
financial scenarios to determine the best suiting hybrid clean energy
system. Therefore, the proposed systems correspond to combinations of
conventional grid, solar panels, wind turbines, and a geothermal unit.
These hybrid systems will be properly dimensioned and afterwards,
compared economically against the conventional system (i.e., use of the
grid) in terms of their net present costs (NPC). The system with the
lowest NPC will be chosen for construction. Another objective to be
achieved in the project is to expand the overall area of the bus shelter in
order to accommodate a larger number (more realistic) number of
passengers needing that service during a regular day.
Existing technology
Accessibility and protection from weather conditions of public bus
stops has been found to increase ridership while moderating harsh
ambient effects on ground passengers waiting for a bus [17]. Therefore,
closed bus shelters emerged as a mean to increase public transport
usage in areas subject to severe ambient conditions, which if managed
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.seta.2019.100544
Received 2 November 2018; Received in revised form 15 June 2019; Accepted 12 September 2019
⁎
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: luis.rojas@nu.edu.kz (L. Rojas-Solórzano).
Sustainable Energy Technologies and Assessments 36 (2019) 100544
2213-1388/ © 2019 Published by Elsevier Ltd.
T