Conservatory education of a musical
savant with autism: a case study in Turkey
Sule Erden and Gonul Reyhanoglu
Abstract
Purpose – Savant syndrome, a very rare condition in the world, refers to individuals who have extraordinary
talents but might have disabilities that prevent them from maintaining their life. The purpose of this paper is to
investigate the views of conservatory instructors about the education of Buğra Çankır (BC), a musical savant
with autism.
Design/methodology/approach – As it was difficult to communicate with BC and elicit his views, interviews
were conducted with his teachers, who had similar experiences in his music education process. The
participants were six instructors who worked as full-time instructors in the conservatory. The participants
were administered a semi-structured focus group interview form that described the difficulties, experiences,
perceptions and feelings they had in their interactions with BC. Data obtained from the study were subjected
to content analysis methods performed by the researchers; analysis involved identification of the codes and
themes and formation of sub-themes and codes in line with these themes.
Findings – Results showed that the participants had difficulties in teaching BC because of having insufficient
knowledge about his features. In addition, while planning the conservatory education processes, the
participants were found to redesign the teaching content considering the features of the student.
Research limitations/implications – The present case study is important in terms of revealing the
problems experienced in the education processes of these individuals. More detailed qualitative studies or
action research could be utilised in studies to be conducted in the future.
Originality/value – BC’s educational experience is the first case for educational institutions and instructors
in Turkey.
Keywords Musical savant with autism, Absolute pitch, Conservatory education
Paper type Case study
Introduction
Savant syndrome, a very rare condition in the world, refers to individuals who have extraordinary
talents but might have disabilities that prevent them from maintaining their life (Miller, 1998).
Despite having below-average intelligence levels, individuals with savant syndrome could have
talents such as calendar calculation (Cowan and Frith, 2009), arithmetic (Heavey, 2004), poem
(Dowker et al., 1996), art (Hermelin and O’Connor, 1970), memory (Treffert, 2009) and music
(Sloboda et al., 1985), (in Pring et al., 2012), which is the focus of this study, too. Rimland and
Fein (1988) found Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) in approximately 10 per cent of the group
who had savant talents (in Stanutz, 2009). It is reported that not all savants have ASD. Males
could have four times more savant features in comparison to females (Treffert, 2009).
The most common savant talent seen in individuals with ASD is music, and these individuals are
reported to have absolute pitch (Miller, 1998). Absolute pitch, which is a very rare talent in music
(Baharloo et al., 2000), is defined as the ability to identify a tone’s pitch or to produce a tone at a
particular pitch without the use of an external reference pitch (Takeuchi and Hulse, 1993). Individuals
on the autism spectrum, musical savants are known to have an excellent long-term memory and
extraordinary melodic memory required for music (Wallace et al., 2009, in Kısaç and Tortop, 2010).
However, these people do not have the basic functional skills such as social interaction,
communication and self-care (Baharloo et al., 2000; Takeuchi and Hulse, 1993).
Received 19 November 2018
Revised 21 January 2019
Accepted 10 March 2019
All authors declare that they have
no conflict of interests. The authors
would like to thank to BC, who
created the present study, and his
family for accepting to participate
in this study. The authors also
thank to Rectorate of Iskenderun
Technical University (ISTE) and
Directorate of ISTE Mustafa Yazıcı
State Conservatory for giving the
permission and support required
for the data collection phase. The
authors would also like to give the
heartfelt thanks to ISTE Mustafa
Yazıcı State Conservatory
instructors for sharing their views
and experiences.
Sule Erden is based at the
Department of Primary
Education, Cukurova
Universitesi, Adana, Turkey.
Gonul Reyhanoglu is based at
the Department of Turkish
Language and Literature, Hatay
Mustafa Kemal University,
Antakya, Turkey.
PAGE 282
j
ADVANCES IN AUTISM
j
VOL. 5 NO. 4 2019, pp. 282-292, © Emerald Publishing Limited, ISSN 2056-3868 DOI 10.1108/AIA-11-2018-0046