Biotropica. 2019;00:1–11. wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/btp
|
1 © 2019 The Association for Tropical Biology and
Conservation
1 | INTRODUCTION
Plant–pollinator interactions are one of the most critical rela‐
tionships maintaining ecosystem function (Ollerton, Winfree
& Tarrant, 2011), and our understanding of them has benefited
considerably from network analyses (Watts, Dormann, Martín
González & Ollerton, 2016). However, not all networks have
been studied to the same extent. In a recent review, Vizentin‐
Bugoni et al. (2018) quantify the proportion of pollination net‐
work studies from tropical, relative to temperate, locales and
point out that within the tropics, studies from Africa are es‐
pecially scarce. In terms of nectivorous pollination networks,
Africa is again understudied (Zanata et al., 2017). They list eight
Received: 3 December 2018
|
Revised: 25 March 2019
|
Accepted: 10 April 2019
DOI: 10.1111/btp.12669
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Promiscuous pollinators—Evidence from an Afromontane
sunbird–plant pollen transport network
Charles A. Nsor
1,2
| William Godsoe
3
| Hazel M. Chapman
2,4,5
*Nsor and Chapman are Joint first authors.
1
Department of Biology, Gombe State
University, Tudun Wada, Nigeria
2
Nigerian Montane Forest Project, Taraba
State, Nigeria
3
Bioprotection Centre, Lincoln University,
Lincoln, New Zealand
4
School of Biology, University of Canterbury,
Canterbury, New Zealand
5
School of Biological Sciences, University of
Canterbury, Christchurch, New Zealand
Correspondence
Hazel M. Chapman, School of Biological
Sciences, University of Canterbury, PB
4800, Christchurch, New Zealand.
Email: hazel.chapman@canterbury.ac.nz
Abstract
Sunbirds play a major role in the pollination of Old World nectivorous plants.
However, with the exception of the Cape Floristic Region there is a major knowl‐
edge gap around African nectivore interaction networks—a stark contrast from
the abundance of neotropical hummingbird–plant networks. Here, we describe a
sunbird pollen transfer network (PTN) which we use in conjunction with a sunbird
flower visitation network (FVN) to explore levels of sunbird specialization within an
Afromontane forest habitat. Both networks were generalized compared with similar‐
sized hummingbird networks, reflecting the wide range of flower types visited, the
generalist diet, and bill characteristics of sunbirds. Three sunbird species from the
genus Cinnyris accounted for 85% of flower visits and 77% of all pollen transported.
Of the 17 plant species across both networks, 15 are predominantly pollinated by in‐
sects while Anthonotha noldeae (Fabaceae–Caesalpinioideae) and Globimetula braunii
(Loranthaceae) depend on sunbirds for seed set. Sunbird species average bill lengths
varied between 14.5 mm (the variable sunbird) and 23.6 mm (the Green‐headed
Sunbird), but, while more pollen was carried on longer bills, we found no evidence
for a relationship between bill length and type of flower visited. Both networks were
nested. Some specialization was observed in both networks although this does not
appear to be driven much by sunbird–flower trait matching. Overall, our results sug‐
gest that in contrast to nectivores elsewhere, factors such as phenology and/or en‐
vironment, rather than morphology, may play important roles in limiting potential
sunbird–flower interactions and need further investigation.
KEYWORDS
flower visitation, generalist pollinators, Ngel Nyaki, Nigeria, pollination mutualism,
specialization
Associate Editor: Emilio Bruna
Handling Editor: Carlos Garcia‐Robledo