ISSN 0033-2941 DOI 10.2466/07.PR0.116k14w0
© Psychological Reports 2015
Psychological Reports: Mental & Physical Health
CONFIDENCE: A CRITICAL REVIEW OF THE LITERATURE AND
AN ALTERNATIVE PERSPECTIVE FOR GENERAL AND SPECIFIC
SELF-CONFIDENCE
1
EMRAH ONEY AND GIZEM OKSUZOGLU-GUVEN
University of Mediterranean Karpasia, Nicosia, Cyprus, Turkey
Summary.—This article provides a critical review of the literature pertaining
to self-confidence and advances the argument of the need to separate the construct
into its general and specific domains. The rationale is that distinguishing self-confi-
dence into general and specific will increase conceptual parsimony and predictive
power of each construct.
Self-confidence is a defining characteristic capable of influencing in-
dividuals' behaviour. As such, it has attracted the attention of research-
ers from many cognate fields (i.e., psychology, marketing, medicine, and
law). For example, self-confidence has been considered to be a predictor of
buying behaviour and household consumption (Chakrabarty, Chopin, &
Darrat, 1998), an influencer of information seeking behaviour (Locander &
Hermann, 1979), a moderator of expectations (Yi & La, 2003), an anteced-
ent of brand commitment (Sung & Choi, 2010), and a predictor of sports
performance (Vealey, 1986). However, despite the frequent use of self-con-
fidence to predict behaviours and behavioural outcomes, its conceptual-
ization and definition vary considerably. The diversity in its conceptualiza-
tion, as argued in this article, needs to be eliminated if future studies are
to provide incremental knowledge and a unified theory of self-confidence.
This article offers a critical review of the existing literature and distin-
guishes confidence into its specific and general domains as a way of mini-
mising conceptual diversity. More specifically, various definitions of confi-
dence are presented first, followed by a discussion pertaining to the way in
which self-confidence differs from similar constructs (i.e., trust, self-efficacy,
and self-esteem). Next, the distinction of self-confidence into its general and
specific domains is made, and it is argued that when self-confidence is seen as
two constructs (i.e., general and specific), definition convergence is likely to be
reached and the predictive power of each type of self-confidence will increase.
Defining Confidence
The origins of the word confidence can be traced to the Italian word
fiducia, which in turn is related to the word fido, and to the Greek word
2015, 116, 1, 149-163.
1
Address correspondence to E. Oney, Ph.D., Department of Business Administration, Faculty
of Business, University of Mediterranean Karpasia, Nicosia, North Cyprus, via Mersin 10,
Turkey or e-mail (emrah.oney@akun.edu.tr).