1 Huikko E, et al. BMJ Open 2023;13:e065593. doi:10.1136/bmjopen-2022-065593
Open access
Lifelong mental health service use
among 15–22 years old offenders: a
document-based, mixed-methods
descriptive study
Eeva Huikko ,
1
Terhi Aalto-Setälä,
1
Päivi Santalahti,
1,2
Riikka Lämsä,
1,3
Aulikki Ahlgrén-Rimpiläinen
4
To cite: Huikko E, Aalto-
Setälä T, Santalahti P, et al.
Lifelong mental health service
use among 15–22 years
old offenders: a document-
based, mixed-methods
descriptive study. BMJ Open
2023;13:e065593. doi:10.1136/
bmjopen-2022-065593
► Prepublication history and
additional supplemental material
for this paper are available
online. To view these files,
please visit the journal online
(http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/
bmjopen-2022-065593).
RL and AA-R are joint senior
authors.
Received 13 June 2022
Accepted 20 February 2023
1
Mental Health, Finnish Institute
for Health and Welfare, Helsinki,
Finland
2
Child Psychiatry, University of
Turku, Turku, Finland
3
Public health, University of
Helsinki, Helsinki, Finland
4
Forensic Psychiatry, Finnish
Institute for Health and Welfare,
Helsinki, Finland
Correspondence to
Dr Eeva Huikko;
eeva.huikko@thl.fi
Original research
© Author(s) (or their
employer(s)) 2023. Re-use
permitted under CC BY-NC. No
commercial re-use. See rights
and permissions. Published by
BMJ.
ABSTRACT
Objectives Among young offenders, psychiatric morbidity
and comorbidity are common, but our knowledge about
their use of mental health services during childhood and
adolescence is scarce. We aimed to describe the lifelong
use of mental health services of young offenders who have
committed serious crimes.
Design and study setting Using data on forensic
psychiatric examinations of 42 Finnish offenders aged
15–22 years, we analysed the timing and typical patterns
of their prior mental health service use with qualitative and
quantitative content analysis and typification.
Results Young offenders appeared in this study as
children with plenty of perinatal and developmental
risks, and risks related to their family situation and
peer relations. Most subjects were described as having
had emotional or behavioural symptoms, or both, since
childhood. Involvement in mental health services was rare
before the age of 7 years but increased markedly after
that, staying on the same level during adolescence. Five
categories of mental health service users were identified:
(1) continuing service use around a decade (14.3%), (2)
one brief fixed treatment (11.9%), (3) involuntary use of
services (31.0%), (4) evasive use of services (21.4%) and
(5) no mental health service use (21.4%).
Conclusions Young offenders had symptoms from early
ages, but during childhood and adolescence, involvement
in mental health services appeared for most as relatively
short, repetitive or lacking. To help children at risk of
criminal development, a multiprofessional approach,
an early evidence-based intervention for behavioural
symptoms and screening for learning problems, traumatic
experiences and substance use are necessary. Results
can help identify children and adolescents with a risk of
criminal development, to develop mental health services
and to plan further research.
INTRODUCTION
Among young offenders, psychiatric
morbidity and comorbidity are common
1
and can be long-lasting.
2
Factors contributing
to the emergence of violent offences have
been extensively studied. The association
between criminality and adverse childhood
experiences and living conditions is well
documented.
3–8
Williams and colleagues
9
have reported traumatic brain injury to be a
risk factor for early and violent crime. Also,
childhood conduct disorders and neuro-
psychiatric disorders have been shown to
associate with serious crimes later in life, as
well as during adolescence anxiety, hostility
and borderline, paranoid and psychotic
features.
10–15
As for diagnostic evaluations,
the most common disorders among young
offenders with serious crimes are conduct
and personality disorders,
1 13 16–18
followed
by affective and anxiety disorders as well as
substance use disorders.
13 16–20
Despite the clear association between early
criminality and mental health problems, our
knowledge about the use of mental health
services of young offenders during their
childhood and adolescence is scarce. Of 5823
incarcerated Canadian youth, aged 12–24
years, who had mental health treatment
during incarceration, 65% had used mental
health services during the 5 years before
incarceration.
21
In the USA, 36% of 423
first-time offenders, aged 12–18 years, had
used psychiatric services during the 4 months
before their offence.
22
The proportion of life-
long use of specialist mental health services
was 46% among 54 incarcerated adoles-
cent females in the USA
19
and 40% among
270 incarcerated Swedish violent men aged
18–25 years.
13
Of 57 Finnish minors assessed
STRENGTHS AND LIMITATIONS OF THIS STUDY
⇒ As a major strength, we consider our comprehen-
sive data covering multiple informants.
⇒ Additionally, the use of mixed methods in analyses
enables us to create a comprehensive and versatile
picture of the research topic.
⇒ Convenience sample and qualitative study design
limit the generalisability of the results.