Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Resources, Conservation & Recycling
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/resconrec
Full length article
Assessing alternative pre-treatment methods to promote metal recovery in
the leaching of printed circuit boards
T. Moyo*, B.H Chirume, J. Petersen
Minerals-to-Metals Signature Theme, Department of Chemical Engineering, University of Cape Town, South Africa
ARTICLE INFO
Keywords:
E-waste
Printed circuit board
Pre-treatment
Liberation
Recycling
Hydrometallurgy
ABSTRACT
Printed circuit boards are a metals rich fraction of e-waste streams and their recycling to recover the metals
promotes growth of a secondary resources economy. Reported successful cases of PCB recycling are carried out
in large volumes using high-level technology and high capital investment smelter house operations.
Hydrometallurgical processes have the potential to provide an option for the scalable processing of smaller
volumes of PCBs and can be set up at relatively lower capital costs. However, to date, the hydrometallurgical
treatment options available rely on precursor communition processes that also require high capital and energy
costs. This study evaluates the options of using NaOH pre-treatment, milling, combustion and other alternative
PCB pre-treatment methods to promote the leaching of metals which are otherwise inaccessible. A batch of
custom-made PCBs of known and consistent metal content has been used to allow effective comparison. The
effectiveness of each pre-treatment method is evaluated through carrying out an ammoniacal copper leach and
recoveries are compared. X-ray CT scans are used to characterise the boards and map out accessibility of metals
for leaching as well as to demonstrate the effectiveness of each pre-treatment method. Results from the X-ray CT
scans showed 69% of the copper to be located in the inner layers of the PCB rendering chemical pre-treatment
which only exposes metal on the outer surfaces of the board ineffective. It was concluded that an integration of
pre-treatment methods effectively liberates metals without the use of heavily mechanised tools and at relatively
minimum environmental impacts.
1. Introduction
Waste Printed Circuit Boards (PCBs) are a valuable fraction of
electronic waste (e-waste) streams and are often the focal stream of e-
waste recyclers. PCBs form about 1–3% (Widmer et al., 2005; Robinson,
2009) of electronic waste in developed countries and 0.01–1% (Amit,
2008) in developing countries. With electronic waste being one of the
fastest growing waste streams in the world, the global shift towards
sustainable management of resources and the continuous depletion of
high grade virgin ore bodies, there is an increased need to explore re-
cycling options for the metals found in PCBs, as well as characterise and
carry out safe disposal of the residue after recovering the desired me-
tals. In developed countries, waste PCB recycling is typically done in
large volumes at centralised, state-of-the art integrated pyro-hydro-
metallurgical operations which require high capital investment to set
up. Developing countries do not only lack the capital to set up such
operations but also still need to develop their e-waste collection infra-
structure. Furthermore it is questionable whether or not generated
waste volumes are sufficient to justify the setting up of operations such
as the ones found in developed countries. Developing countries have
large resource of unskilled labour and hence recycling operations use
manual dismantling and sorting with operations in China (Wang et al.,
2011; Huo et al., 2007), South Africa (Lydall et al., 2017; Sadan, 2019)
and India (Sadan, 2019) using chisels, hammers and cutting torches in
the dismantling process. In African countries, e-waste recycling is
slowly establishing itself as an industry. However, the focus is primarily
on the collection, sorting and in some instances size reduction then
exporting, usually of the value fractions to be processed elsewhere,
typically in developed countries. The pre-treatment of PCBs varies de-
pending on the intended processing methodology. For integrated
smelter house operations such as that at Umicore’s Hoboken plant
(Hageluken, 2006), size reduction is primarily done in effort to generate
a homogenous sample for analysis prior to processing. In other opera-
tions, pre-treatment (post dismantling and sorting) for the purposes of
upgrading the materials and liberating the metal prior to processing
(akin to the treatment of primary ores) is usually carried out. Shred-
ding, milling and separation/classification are used for liberating and
upgrading the metal content of PCBs. This typically requires heavy duty
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2019.104545
Received 17 May 2019; Received in revised form 17 September 2019; Accepted 11 October 2019
⁎
Corresponding author.
E-mail addresses: thandazile.moyo@uct.ac.za, moyothandazile@gmail.com (T. Moyo).
Resources, Conservation & Recycling 152 (2020) 104545
0921-3449/ © 2019 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
T