https://doi.org/10.1177/0146167218772530
Personality and Social
Psychology Bulletin
1–17
© 2018 by the Society for Personality
and Social Psychology, Inc
Reprints and permissions:
sagepub.com/journalsPermissions.nav
DOI: 10.1177/0146167218772530
pspb.sagepub.com
Empirical Research Paper
Imagine you are at a party with your partner. You stand in
line to get a drink and notice your partner talking and laugh-
ing with an attractive woman you do not know. Later, you
notice the woman’s hand on your partner’s shoulder. How
would you feel when you notice the woman talking with
your partner? Would you immediately feel jealous or not
until she touches your partner? As the situation progresses,
would your feelings and behavior change? Depending on
your relationship history, such jealousy-inducing situations
should trigger specific emotional and cognitive responses
that eventually generate behavioral reactions. This cascade
of responses is likely to have significant consequences for
you, your partner, and your relationship.
Despite the significant role that jealousy plays in people’s
lives, it has rarely been studied as the dynamic, unfolding
experience it truly is. Instead, most prior research has inves-
tigated jealousy by asking people how they felt during a pre-
vious, self-selected jealousy-inducing event. Although such
approaches have produced considerable insight into jealousy,
they do not ascertain how different people respond to the
same jealousy-inducing situation while it occurs. Why do
some people feel jealous when their partner merely glances
at a potential mate, whereas others do not feel jealous until
there is clearer evidence of a mate-poaching attempt? Do
feelings of jealousy and associated negative emotions inten-
sify rapidly or gradually as threat escalates?
These questions cannot be answered without using a para-
digm that (a) standardizes the jealousy situation, (b) allows it
to unfold and intensify over time, and (c) allows individuals
to experience jealousy without harming their relationships.
To answer these questions, we developed a new paradigm—
the Response Escalation Paradigm (REP). Using this para-
digm in three studies, we examine how individuals’ emotional,
cognitive, and behavioral reactions to a hypothetical, escalat-
ing jealousy situation are associated with their romantic
attachment orientations.
The Nature and Functions of Jealousy
Jealousy is
a complex of thoughts, emotions, and actions that follows loss of
or threat to self-esteem and/or the existence or quality of the
romantic relationship [when] the perceived loss or threat is
772530PSP XX X 10.1177/0146167218772530Personality and Social Psychology BulletinHuelsnitz et al.
research-article 2018
1
University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, USA
2
Wayne State University, Detroit, MI, USA
3
The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Israel
Corresponding Author:
Chloe O. Huelsnitz, University of Minnesota, 75 East River Pkwy,
Minneapolis, MN 55455, USA.
Email: miro0047@umn.edu
Attachment and Jealousy: Understanding
the Dynamic Experience of Jealousy Using
the Response Escalation Paradigm
Chloe O. Huelsnitz
1
, Allison K. Farrell
2
, Jeffry A. Simpson
1
,
Vladas Griskevicius
1
, and Ohad Szepsenwol
3
Abstract
Jealousy is a complex, dynamic experience that unfolds over time in relationship-threatening situations. Prior research has
used retrospective reports that cannot disentangle initial levels and change in jealousy in response to escalating threat. In
three studies, we examined responses to the Response Escalation Paradigm (REP)—a 5-stage hypothetical scenario in which
individuals are exposed to increasing levels of relationship threat—as a function of attachment orientations. Highly anxious
individuals exhibited hypervigilant, slow escalation response patterns, interfered earlier in the REP, felt more jealousy,
sadness, and worry when they interfered, and wanted to engage in more vigilant, destructive, and passive behaviors aimed
at their partner. Highly avoidant individuals felt more anger when they interfered in the REP and wanted to engage in more
partner-focused, destructive behaviors. The REP offers a dynamic method for inducing and examining jealousy and introduces
a novel approach to studying other emotional experiences.
Keywords
emotion in relationships, adult attachment, romantic relationships, emotions
Received May 22, 2017; revision accepted March 30, 2018