Navid Zeraatkar, Mohammad R. Ay, Member, IEEE, Saeed Sarkar, Parham Geramifar, and Arman Rahmim
Member, IEEE
Abstract– As the dimensions of crystal elements in modern
PET systems is getting smaller, the fraction of events undergoing
inter-crystal scattering (ICS) and penetration increases. This has
deteriorative impact on the spatial resolution of images. However,
with the utilization of statistical image reconstruction methods in
PET, compensation for ICS and penetration impacts is feasible by
accurately modeling their effects in the projection space. We aim
to perform such a work for the GE Discovery RX (DRX) PET/CT
system. In this work, we investigated ICS and penetration in the
DRX for acquiring a quantitative view of their respective
contributions. We analyzed the events in the form of coincidences
instead of single photons. Also as a novelty, we discriminated
between the origins of the event mispositiong. For this, we applied
the GATE (Geant4 Application for Tomographic Emission)
Monte Carlo toolkit and used our previously validated model of
DRX. Numerous points in different positions were analyzed inside
the field of view (FOV) of DRX. Finally, using geometrical
symmetries of the DRX and interpolation, the fraction of ICS and
penetration could be determined for all possible positions inside
the FOV. The results revealed that the notable variations in
quantitative behavior of ICS and penetration occurred with
varying radial positions; the fraction of ICS/penetration-induced
mispositioned coincidences out of true coincidences ranged from
28.7% at the center to 57.8% at the edge of the transaxial FOV.
This comprehensive quantification of ICS and penetration not
only provides a deeper understanding of their respective
contributions, but is also aimed to be utilized in refining the
This work was supported by the Research Center for Science and
Technology in Medicine under grant No. 88.256.
Navid Zeraatkar is with the Research Center for Science and Technology
in Medicine, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran (e-mail:
navid_zeraatkar@yahoo.com).
Mohammad Reza Ay is with the Department of Medical Physics and
Biomedical Engineering, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran
and Research Center for Science and Technology in Medicine, Tehran, Iran,
and Research Institute for Nuclear Medicine, Tehran University of Medical
Sciences, Tehran, Iran (e-mail: mohammadreza_ay@tums.ac.ir).
Saeed Sarkar is with the Department of Medical Physics and Biomedical
Engineering, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran and
Research Center for Science and Technology in Medicine, Tehran, Iran.
Parham Geramifar is with the Faculty of Physics and Nuclear Engineering,
Amir Kabir University of Technology and Research Center for Science and
Technology in Medicine, Tehran, Iran, and Research Institute for Nuclear
Medicine, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran.
Arman Rahmim is with the Department of Radiology, Johns Hopkins
Medical Institutions, Baltimore, Maryland, USA (e-mail:
arahmim1@jhmi.edu).
system matrix in the image reconstruction task to achieve
resolution modeling in the scanner.
I. INTRODUCTION
hile there is continuing demand for higher resolution in
PET systems, technological improvements are still
challenged by the presence of inter-crystal scatter (ICS) and
inter-crystal penetration phenomena in detectors [1].
Penetration (exhibiting itself in the form of the so-called
parallax effect) occurs when a photon passes through a crystal
on which it is incident with no interaction and is instead
detected in another crystal. The penetration effect is therefore
probable only for photons entering the crystal at non-
perpendicular angles and intensifies as the photon energy
increases and/or the attenuation coefficient of the detector
material decreases. Hence, the probability of a 511-keV
photon in a PET system for penetrating through the incident
crystal with no interaction is considerable. In the other hand,
ICS can be present even for photons incident perpendicularly
to the crystal and happens when a photon escapes from the
crystal it initially entered after one or more Compton
interactions and hence deposits some of its energy in one or
more crystals other than the initial crystal. Fig. 1 depicts an
example of a photon experiencing ICS and penetration in a
typical detector block. Both ICS and penetration have
deteriorative impact on spatial resolution of PET scanners
because they cause some photons to be detected in crystals not
corresponding to the position of the annihilation from which
the photon emitted. The consequence of this photon
mispositioning is that the coincidences in which at least one of
the two photons mispositioned due to ICS or penetration are
likely registered in incorrect line of responses (LORs). In
addition, the current trend of PET detection system
implementation that leans toward fabrication of smaller
crystals for reaching better intrinsic spatial resolution worsens
the impact of ICS and penetration due to the higher probability
of the photon escape from the prime crystal before interaction
or after Compton interaction.
Nonetheless, following the introduction and utility of
statistical image reconstruction methods in PET, and the so-
called system matrix, it has been shown that it is possible to
Quantitative Investigation of Inter-Crystal
Scatter and Penetration in the GE Discovery
RX PET/CT Scanner using Monte Carlo
Simulations
W
2403 978-1-4244-9105-6/10/$26.00 ©2010 IEEE