1
The Moses Complex
The Judeo-European State of Emergency and the Theological Invention of
the Real in Freud and Lacan
Dr. Itzhak Benyamini
itzhak.benyamini@gmail.com
© All rights reserved to Itzhak Benyamini, 2024.
Keynote Lecture in the Catholic Academy in Berlin, September 5, 2024, the workshop
“Jacques Lacan and Religion”
https://intellectualdiaspora.org/culture-of-difference_jacques-lacan-and-religion/
I wish to thank the organizers of the workshop in the Catholic Academy in Berlin on
“Jacques Lacan and Religion”, Dr. Stephan Steiner and Prof. Christoph Seibert. Their
invitation allowed me to rethink Lacan’s treatment of theological themes embedded in
Freud’s work on the figure of the biblical Moses. This re-thinking is crucial for the topic
of our conference, since Lacan perceived the book “Moses the Man and the Religion of
Monotheism”, published in 1939, as Freud’s will.
In my lecture I will follow Lacan’s consideration in seminar 7, “The Ethics of
Psychoanalysis”, regarding Freud’s insistence on writing a work that is, according to
Lacan, both mythological and “imaginary” and at the same time Christian in nature. The
book is perceived as Christian due to the central theme of the death of the “great man”,
as an echo of the crucifixion of Christ. This theme follows “Totem and Taboo” in which
the primordial father was murdered and has reincarnated as a God. In his late writing
Freud again discusses the murder of a primordial father like Moses whose horrifying
figure is being transformed into the super-ego of the Jewish Torah.
Lacan points at Freud’s decisive assumption, that two different historical figures
stand behind the biblical figure of Moses. This theme will serve me as a quilting point
for analyzing Freud’s work. I will interrogate the way that Jewish presence in Europe
has formed Freud’s identity and the way Lacan translated it into his own conceptual
space.
If I may refer to my own status as I speak to you now; my own political anxiety, as
an Israeli Jewish person, speaking in a European academic space, is inflected by the
chronic antisemitism, that is far from being a by-gone relic of Freud’s time.
Freud is splitting the biblical Moses into two different figures, which the Jews
encountered in two different points in time, separate by hundreds of years; The first,
Egyptian Moses, represents the principles of the Egyptian empire and promotes the
theological monotheistic-rational agenda of the Pharaoh Akhenaton. Many years later
the second, Midianite Moses emerged as a priest of the furious God of the desert,
Yahweh, the God who speaks through the bush, a God that is not universal but expresses
a paranoid narcissistic fanaticism. According to Lacan, this observation allows us to
extract two separate logics of Western theologies: On the one hand, the abstract,
philosophical, Aristotelian logic, and on the other hand, the religious and more affective
logic, manifest in the biblical texts.