VOL. 84-B, NO. 4, MAY 2002 579
P. J. B. Hallam, FRCS, Registrar
M. A. Fazal, MA, FRCS, Registrar
H. E. Ware, FRCS, Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon
Chase Farm Hospital NHS Trust, The Ridgeway, Enfield, Middlesex EN2
8JL, UK.
N. Ashwood, FRCS, Orthopaedic Registrar
Whittington Hospital, Highgate Hill, London N19 5NF, UK.
M. M. S. Glasgow, FRCS, Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon
Norfolk and Norwich Health Care NHS Trust, Brunswick Road, Norwich,
Norfolk, UK.
J. M. Powell, FRCS, Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon
The Ipswich Hospital NHS Trust, Heath Road, Ipswich, Suffolk 1P4 SPD,
UK.
Correspondence should be sent to Mr P. J. B. Hallam at 8, St James
School, Georges Road, London N7 8HD, UK.
©2002 British Editorial Society of Bone and Joint Surgery
0301-620X/02/410372 $2.00
An alternative to fixation of displaced
fractures of the anterior intercondylar
eminence in children
P. J. B. Hallam, M. A. Fazal, N. Ashwood, H. E. Ware,
M. M. S. Glasgow, J. M. Powell
From Chase Farm Hospital NHS Trust, Enfield, England
F
ractures of the anterior intercondylar eminence in
children are relatively uncommon. There is
considerable debate as to the best treatment of
displaced fractures, but most methods described in the
literature involve an open procedure combined with
some form of fixation. Using human anatomical
dissections, we have shown that the transverse
meniscal ligament can become incarcerated within the
fracture and act as a block to reduction. We describe
an arthroscopic technique which requires no fixation
device and report the results of its use in eight
displaced fractures. This method gives reliable results
and offers the advantage of less potential morbidity.
J Bone Joint Surg [Br] 2002;84-B:579-82.
Received 19 July 2000; Accepted after revision 3 November 2000
The anterior intercondylar eminence of the tibia lies
between the anterior poles of the menisci, anterior to the
anterior tibial spine (Fig. 1). The anterior cruciate ligament
is attached to it. Fractures in this area are uncommon in
adolescence with a reported annual incidence of 3 in
100 000. They have been classified into three types by
Meyers and McKeever.
2
Type I is the least severe with
minimal displacement of the avulsed fragment and a high
degree of bone apposition. Type II is displaced, but retains
some apposition to the intercondylar eminence and type III
is displaced with no apposition (Fig. 2). A modification of
this classification describes a type-IV fracture in which the
fragment is displaced and comminuted.
3
While most authors agree that undisplaced type-I frac-
tures should be treated conservatively, there is much debate
as to the best treatment of displaced type-II and type-III
fractures. Most treatments described for displaced fractures
involve some form of open reduction and internal fixation
using absorbable sutures,
2
multiple pins,
3
Kirschner wires
4
wire sutures
5
or screws.
6
We undertook a clinical and cadaver study which identi-
fied the transverse meniscal ligament as the main obstacle
to reduction and now describe an arthroscopic technique to
treat these fractures without internal fixation.
Patients and Methods
We performed the anatomical study on five fresh adult (two
male, three female) cadaver knees which were dissected
leaving the anterior structures intact. The anterior inter-
condylar eminence was osteotomised to simulate a dis-
placed fracture and the structures incarcerated within the
fracture identified. The best method of reduction of the
fracture was then sought and the reduction compared with
the knee held in flexion and extension.
For the clinical study, we treated and followed up eight
adolescents (six girls, two boys) with a mean age of 12.6
years (11 to 14) with type-II or type-III fractures of the
anterior intercondylar eminence, according to Meyers and
McKeever,
2
as judged by plain anteroposterior and lateral
radiographs. There were five fractures of the left knee and
three of the right. Although patients were unable to describe
the exact mechanism of injury, three fractures occurred
after a fall from a cycle and the remaining five during
sporting activities. Six were type-II and two were type-III
injuries. All patients underwent examination under anaes-
thesia and arthroscopy within 48 hours of injury. After
washout of the haemarthrosis, the transverse meniscal liga-
ment was seen to obstruct reduction. Using a probe, the
ligament was pulled out of the site of the fracture which
was then reduced by firm pressure. The reduction could be
maintained by keeping the knee in hyperextension. An
above-knee plaster cylinder was then applied with the knee
in the hyperextended position. After observation overnight,