44
Motor Control, 2010, 14, 44-58
© 2010 Human Kinetics, Inc.
Does Perception Asymmetrically Influence
Motor Production in Upper and Lower
Visual Fields?
K. Brownell, T. Rolheiser, M. Heath, and G. Binsted
The authors examined if previously reported anatomical asymmetries between the
upper (uVF) and lower visual fields (lVF) influence the preparation and control
of visually and memory-guided reaching movements. To manipulate visual field,
participants maintained their visual gaze on a cue position presented above or below
the location of a target object, thus resulting in reaches completed in respective
uVF and lVF of peripersonal. In Experiment 1, participants performed reaches to
four targets with indices of difficulty ranging from 3.1 to 5.1 bits under five visual-
memory conditions: full vision and memory-guided conditions entailing 0, 2, 5, and
10 s of delay. In Experiment 2, participants reached to the vertex of Müller-Lyer
figures in 3 visual-memory conditions: full vision, and memory-guided conditions
entailing 0, and 2 s of delay. In accord with duplex theories of vision (e.g., Milner
& Goodale, 1992), it was hypothesized that the introduction of a visual delay and/
or the introduction of context-dependent illusory structure would differentially
bias the efficiency and effectiveness of uVF and lVF reaches. Although data
displayed mixed supported for the existence of an lVF advantage for movement
execution, neither the introduction of delay nor contextual illusions succeeded in
differentiating visual fields. Thus, performance advantages for movements made
in the lower visual field do not appear associated with preferential connections to
parietal (i.e., dorsal-action) and temporal (i.e., ventral-perception) architectures.
While various dichotomous accounts of action production have circulated
for over a century (e.g., Woodwoorth 1899; Beggs & Howarth 1972; Keele,
1968; Meyer et al. 1988; see Elliott et al. 2001 for a review), the suggestion of
two autonomously functioning visual streams is much more recent (in macaque:
“what” versus “where”, Ungerleider & Mishkin 1979; Mishkin & Ungerleider 1982;
“form” versus “motion”, Hubel & Livingstone, 1987). Goodale and Milner (1992)
proposed the existence of two streams of visual processing extending through the
extrastriate cortex and diverging into two distinct streams: dorsally via the posterior
parietal cortex (PPC) and ventrally via the inferior temporal lobe (IT). Contrary
Brownell is with the College of Kinesiology, University of Saskatchewan. Rolheiser is with the Dept.
of Human Physiology, University of Oregon. Heath is with the School of Kinesiology, University of
Western Ontario. Binsted is with the Faculty of Health and Social Development, University of British
Columbia, Okanagan.