Transport buyers choice of transport service – A literature review of
empirical results
Jonas Flodén ⁎, Fredrik Bärthel, Edith Sorkina
Department of Business Administration, School of Business, Economics and Law, University of Gothenburg, Gothenburg, Sweden
1. Introduction
Understanding the choice of transport service is a key issue in under-
standing the transport market, designing a competitive transport sys-
tem and, in particular, achieving a shift towards intermodal transport.
The selection of transport service has received increased interest in re-
cent years, particularly in relation to the increased focus on intermodal
transport, caused by large political focus on reducing the dominance of
road transport and thus leading to subsequent large research attention
to intermodality (cf. Bontekoning, Macharis, & Trip, 2004; European
Commission, 2001). To recognize the challenges in attracting freight to
intermodal transport and to design a competitive transport system in
general, it is of key importance to identify which factors are important
to the customer. A core component in intermodal research is thus to
study the modal split and competition between transport modes. The
modal choice is a decision made based on the combined performance
of a number of factors, such as price and quality, where the different ac-
tors have different values, perceptions, and criteria for the selection of
transport solutions (Woxenius & Bärthel, 2008). To understand the
modal choice thus requires an understanding of the underlying factors.
This knowledge is not only important for industry actors in designing
competitive transport solutions, but also for society in help building
and supporting an efficient transport system. Policymakers in particular
have a keen interest in understanding the challenges and opportunities
associated with the different modes of transport and potential transport
services.
Consequently, choice of transport service has received large interest
in the research community and several studies have been conducted.
However, the studies show disparate results to some extent and have
been conducted in different settings, with different focus and using dif-
ferent methods. Thus, there is a need to summarise and compare these
different studies to gain a better understanding of the factors influenc-
ing the choice of transport service.
The purpose of this paper is to make a literature review and compar-
ison of previous studies on the transport service choice for freight and to
identify important factors behind the choice. Implications for
intermodal transport will be considered in particular. What separates
this literature review from previous reviews (e.g., Meixell & Norbis,
2008 and Karlsson, 2008) is a focus on the actual mapping of real cus-
tomer attitudes and preferences and a widened scope, which includes
non-peer reviewed sources. Implications for business and management
include a better knowledge of customer demands, which could help
managers design more competitive transport systems.
The review focuses on peer-reviewed European studies during the
last 26 years, from 1990 to 2016, published in English and Swedish.
The peer-reviewed studies are complemented by non-peer review pub-
lications, or the so-called “grey literature” of reports and on-line publi-
cations. Today, much research is only published outside the traditional
academic channels and to completely ignore this research bears the
risk of missing relevant studies (White, 2014; Woxenius, 2015). How-
ever, it is important to recognize the potential difference in research
quality between these groups and to keep them separate when
analysing the data. Publications in Swedish were selected since the au-
thors are Swedish and are familiar with possible publication sources.
The review includes studies on European conditions based on pri-
mary data. Thus, it is a requirement that the study has made some
kind of empirical data collection where the actual opinion of the trans-
port customer has been studied. It does not include modelling ap-
proaches or analyses based on statistical data. Cases studies were also
excluded. To only include studies that have directly collected data
from the transport customer is likely to come closest to revealing the
real influencing factors.
The paper starts with an introduction, followed by a methodology
section, after which the review results are presented. This is followed
by analysis and conclusions.
2. Methodology
A four-step approach was applied for the literature review. Firstly, a
large scientific database was used to find peer-reviewed journal publi-
cations. Science Direct, one of the largest databases covering more
than 12 million articles, was used. A list of relevant actors and activities
were identified by the authors and used in the search in all fields in the
database. The actors identified included shippers, forwarders, carriers,
transport customers, hauliers, transport service providers, logistics ser-
vice providers, consignors, and consignees. The activities identified
were selection, perception, preferences, and behaviour/behavior. Each
Research in Transportation Business & Management xxx (2017) xxx–xxx
⁎ Corresponding author at: School of Business, Economics and Law, University of
Gothenburg, Box 610, 40530 Gothenburg, Sweden.
E-mail address: jonas.floden@handels.gu.se (J. Flodén).
RTBM-00276; No of Pages 11
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.rtbm.2017.02.001
2210-5395/© 2017 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Research in Transportation Business & Management
Please cite this article as: Flodén, J., et al., Transport buyers choice of transport service – A literature review of empirical results, Research in Trans-
portation Business & Management (2017), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.rtbm.2017.02.001