Abstract #9017
Board #260
Plasma-Based Monitoring of BRAF Mutations During Therapy for Malignant Melanoma
Using Combined Exosomal RNA and Cell-Free DNA Analysis
Sullivan RJ
1
, O’Neill VJ
2
, Enderle D
3
, Valentino M
2
, Koestler T
3
, Blackmon S
1
, Krug AK
3
, Brinkmann K
3
, Spiel A
3
, Bentink S
3
, Mueller R
3
, Emenegger J
3
, Noerholm M
3
,
Skog J
2
, Berking C
4
, Flaherty K
1
Background and Methods
Oncogenic mutations in BRAF (V600E/V600K) are present in 40-50% of patients
with malignant melanoma (MM) and represent an important therapeutic target (e.g.,
vemurafenib). Blood-based, serial monitoring of BRAF and other mutations during
therapy may be useful to inform time-critical treatment decisions. Plasma contains at
least two sources of cell-free nucleic acids (NAs) where tumor derived mutations
can be detected: exosomal RNA (exoRNA) and cell-free DNA (cfDNA). Circulating
NAs provide an important opportunity to monitor cancer longitudinally to assess
treatment response and disease progression. In patients with aggressive disease,
such as MM, timely insights about treatment response and disease progression
are paramount in order to help guide and adjust treatment decisions. Combining
exoRNA and cfDNA maximizes the yield of genetic material from plasma, and may
enable monitoring of both biologically important sources to enhance mutation
detection sensitivity and help match patients to targeted therapies.
Blood was drawn from 12 metastatic MM patients for analysis prior to therapy
initiation and up to 10 time points after. Subsequent purification of high-quality NAs
using a novel, spin-column based method (EXO52) to co-isolate all exoRNA and
cfDNA allowed analysis of mutations present in both NA fractions by ultra-deep
sequencing. A custom next-generation sequencing (NGS) library preparation
method with a novel bioinformatics pipeline to efficiently identify rare mutations
(EXO1000 Solid Tumor Panel), was used to analyze a panel of nine mutation
hotspots from six genes, including BRAF. Data were correlated with tissue-based
mutational analysis, treatment information, and RECIST-defined response
assessments.
Extracellular RNA and DNA in plasma. Exosomes are actively released by living cells
directly from the plasma membrane (A) or via the multivesicular body pathway (A’),
carrying RNA into circulation (exoRNA). Apoptotic or necrotic cells may release cell-
free DNA (cfDNA) in apoptotic vesicles (B) or as free-circulating nucleosomes (B’).
apopto%c / necro%c cell
living cell
A
A’
B
B’
• Extracellular vesicles, mainly 50-200 nm in size, are actively
secreted by the cell and carry a snapshot of the body’s
transcriptome (exoRNA).
• Circulating cell-free DNA (cfDNA) is released by necrotic and
apoptotic events in tumor and normal tissue.
exoRNA and cfDNA: Two distinct sources of
cell-free nucleic acids in plasma
Summary and Conclusions
• Using EXO52 spin columns and EXO1000 NGS analysis, we detected and
quantified mutant BRAF levels in 12 of 12 patients with BRAF mutant melanoma.
• Mutant BRAF levels were reduced in 11 of the 12 patients in the setting of BRAFi
therapy and in every one of the 10 RECIST-defined responders.
• Mutant BRAF levels were increased at time of PD to BRAFi in 9 of 10 patients.
• Mutant BRAF levels were increased in advance of PD in 5 of 10 patients.
• The two patients in whom mutant BRAF levels were not increased (or minimally
increased) at time of PD had progressing leptomeningeal disease (LMD) in the
setting of ongoing non-LMD response.
• The EXO52 technology platform enabled longitudinal monitoring of BRAF
mutant melanoma and demonstrated the ability to detect early disease
progression prior to radiographic changes.
Complete BRAFi regimen Vem Dab + Tram Enco + Bini
Total treated 2 5 5
Best response
PD 1 0 1
SD 0 0 1
PR 1 4 3
CR 0 1 0
Eventual progression 2 4 4
BRAF MUT decreased on treatment 2 5 4
BRAF MUT increased @ PD 2 3 4
BRAF MUT increased before PD 1 2 2
EXO1000 analysis predicts disease progression in advance of
clinical or radiographic progression
BRAFi = BRAF inhibitor
MEKi = MEK inhibitor
PR = partial response
PD = progressive disease
CR = complete response
SD = stable disease
Dab + Tram = dabrafenib plus trametinib
Enco + Bini = encorafenib plus binimetinib
Vem = vemurafenib
MUT = mutations
(1) Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, MA, USA | (2) Exosome Diagnostics Inc., Cambridge, MA, USA | (3) Exosome Diagnostics GmbH, Munich, Germany | (4) Ludwig-Maximilians University, Munich, Germany
MGH11276-032
0
1
20
300
5,000
V600E cp/ml
BL PR PR PR PR PR PR PR PD PD PD
Tumor
encorafenib
binimetinib ipilimumab
dabrafenib
trametinib
0
20
40
V600E %
0
10k
20k
BRAF
BNE
W 2
W 4
M 2
M 4
M 6
M 8
M10
M12
M14
M16
B 2
Example 1: BRAF mutant signal
4 months before clinical progression
Early detection of progression. Detailed outline of a single patient’s
longitudinal liquid biopsies during treatment. In this patient, two weeks
after initiation of BRAFi/MEKi treatment (W2), the V600E mutant copies
drop below detection level, following radiological response by RECIST
(PR). A substantial mutant signal at month 10 of treatment predicts the
clinical progression (PD) 4 months ahead (arrow).
exoRNA+cfDNA
cfDNA
exoRNA+cfDNA
cfDNA
signal before PD
BRAF
KRAS
NRAS
EGFR
Actionable
mutations
PIK3CA
C
EXO52 single-step isolation
of exoRNA and cfDNA
Targeted resequencing
Fresh or archived
plasma
MEK1
RECIST; lesion length
exoRNA+cfDNA copies / ml
cfDNA copies / ml
treatment information
mutant % of NGS reads
total gene copies / ml
Patient data time course
A B
Workflow of the EXO1000 Solid Tumor Panel: EXO52 co-isolation of exoRNA and cfDNA from 0.5-4 mL of fresh or
archived plasma, pre-filtered with 0.8 µm to exclude cellular material (A and B); Targeted enrichment, sequencing on the
Illumina MiSeq
TM
platform and absolute quantification of input material; Bioinformatic analysis that includes noise
correction and calculation of mutant copy numbers (C). Data is presented as outline of a single patient’s longitudinal liquid
biopsies during treatment (D). Shown are 4 panels which contain mutant copies per ml plasma (EXO52 copies depicted
in blue, cfDNA copies depicted in orange), RECIST classification and tumor volume relative to baseline (green circles),
the noise-corrected mutant %, and total gene copies per ml plasma (EXO52 copies depicted in light grey).
D
Using the EXO1000 Solid Tumor Panel in monitoring
circulating mutations of patients with MM
MGH11276-048
0
10
20
30
V600E cp/ml
BL PR PR deceased
dabrafenib
trametinib
Tumor
0
0.5
1
1.5
V600E %
0
4k
0k
BRAF
BNE
W 2
W 4
M 2
M 4
Example 2: Low signal from
patients with progressing LMD
Progression on leptomeningeal disease. Detailed outline of a single
patient’s longitudinal liquid biopsies during treatment. This patient is one
out of two patients with systemic and leptomeningeal disease (LMD)
which commenced on BRAFi/MEKi treatment. While both patients had
treatment response per RECIST, improvement of LMD symptoms
followed by an decrease in BRAF levels (no signal at first PR), only the
displayed patient had a small but detectable mutation signal before
progression of LMD.
exoRNA+cfDNA
cfDNA
exoRNA+cfDNA
cfDNA
Progression on LMD
Plasma-based monitoring of BRAF mutations with EXO1000
MGH11276-003
0
4210
8421
12631
16842
V600K cp/ml
BNE
W 2
W 4
M 2
M 4
M 6
M 8
M10
BL PR CR PD SD PD deceased
dabrafenib
trametinib
none
MPDL3280A
ipilimumab
MGH11276-021
0
964
1929
2893
3857
V600E cp/ml
BNE
W 2
W 4
M 2
M 4
M 6
M 8
M10
M12
M14
BL PD PD PD PD PD PD deceased
ipilimumab vemurafenib
dabrafenib
trametinib
dabrafenib
trametinib
bevacizumab
dabrafenib
trametinib
temozolomide
MGH11276-036
0
1623
3245
4868
6490
V600E cp/ml
BNE
W 2
W 4
M 2
M 4
M 6
M 8
M10
M12
M14
M18
BL SD SD SD SD PD PD PD
encorafenib
binimetinib
dabrafenib
trametinib
dabrafenib
trametinib
ipilimumab
none
MGH11276-001
0
1132
2264
3396
4528
V600K cp/ml
BNE
W 2
W 4
M 2
M 4
M 6
M 8
BL PR PD PD deceased
vemurafenib
ipilimumab
dacarbacine
abemaciclib
MGH11276-002
0
118
236
353
471
V600K cp/ml
BNE
W 2
W 4
M 2
M 4
BL PR PD deceased
dabrafenib
trametinib
MGH11276-053
0
24
48
72
96
V600E cp/ml
BNE
W 2
W 4
M 2
M 4
M 6
BL PR PD
dabrafenib
trametinib
dabrafenib
trametinib
ipilimumab
MGH11276-038
0
225
450
676
901
V600E cp/ml
BNE
W 2
W 4
M 2
BL SD SD deceased
encorafenib
binimetinib
MGH11276-040
0
8174
16347
24521
32695
V600E cp/ml
BNE
W 2
W 4
M 2
BL PD PD deceased
encorafenib
binimetinib
LMU100
0
95
191
286
381
V600E cp/ml
2013-02-04
2013-07-30
2013-10-22
2014-05-06
2014-08-26
PD PR SD
Monitoring BRAFi treatment with EXO1000. Simple outline of a single patient’s longitudinal liquid biopsies during treatment. EXO52
mutant copies per mL plasma are plotted in blue and RECIST-define tumor lesion length is visualized as green circles.
0 4 16 80 200 500
0
0.01
0.3
10
100
Treatment substantially decreases
BRAF mutant levels until progression
Levels of BRAF V600E and V600K mutant during BRAFi treatment.
Every colored line corresponds to a single patient in this study. Mutant
BRAF copies relative to baseline (V600E or V600K) are shown starting
at treatment onset (Day 0) to first indication of progression based on
clinical or radiographical evidence (end of plotted line).
Mutant Copies (% of baseline, log2)
BRAF mutant levels during BRAFi
treatment of malignant melanoma
Days of treatment (log2)
© 2015 Exosome Diagnostics, Inc.
MGH11276-020
0
300
600
V600E cp/ml
BL PR PR PR PR PR PR PR PR PD
encorafenib
binimetinib none
Tumor
0
10
20
V600E %
0
6k
12k
BRAF
BNE
W 2
W 4
M 2
M 4
M 6
M 8
M10
M12
M14
M16
Example 3: Monitoring of
long-term treatment success
Successful therapy and relapse. Detailed outline of a single
patient’s longitudinal liquid biopsies during treatment. This patient
showed continuous response to BRAFi/MEKi therapy, indicated by
radiographic evidence and sustained low BRAF mutation levels (PR,
arrow). Eventually, this patient elected to be removed from study due
to quality of life reasons, and at time of next follow-up had an
increase in mutant signal and that corresponded to progression of
disease (PD).
exoRNA+cfDNA
cfDNA
exoRNA+cfDNA
cfDNA
no signal during successful treatment
PD
2015 ASCO Annual Meeting, May 29 – June 2, 2015, Chicago, IL, USA Contact: Hannah@exosomedx.com