Received: 23 October 2018 Revised: 20 May 2019 Accepted: 3 July 2019
DOI: 10.1002/pts.2473
RESEARCH ARTICLE
Prediction of cushion curves of polymer foams using a
nonlinear distributed parameter model
Amin Joodaky
1
Gregory S. Batt
2
James M. Gibert
1
1
Advanced Dynamics and Mechanics Lab, Ray
W. Herrick Laboratories, School of Mechanical
Engineering, Purdue University, IN 47907, USA
2
Department of Food, Nutrition, and Packaging
Sciences, Clemson University, SC 29634, USA
Correspondence
Amin Joodaky, School of Mechanical
Engineering, Purdue University, West
Lafayette, IN 47907, USA.
Email: ajoodaky@purdue.edu
Funding information
Purdue Research Foundation
Polymer foams are commonly used in the protective packaging of fragile products.
Cushion curves are commonly used within the packaging industry to characterize
a foam's impact performance. These curves are two-dimensional representations
of the deceleration of an impacting mass versus static stress. Cushion curves are
currently generated from exhaustive experimental test data. This study represents
the first time that the physics of the mass-cushion impact have been analysed by
modelling the foam as nonlinear, continuous rod. Using a single mode of vibration and
excluding the effects of damping, the maximum displacement during the impact can
be obtained from a polynomial describing the maximum elastic energy in the foam.
The displacements can be used to recover the amplitude of the deceleration shock
pulse. Numerical and analytical analysis of the model with damping is considered
in its ability to predict the shock pulse shape, duration, and amplitude at various
static stresses, foam thickness, and drop heights as compared with experimental data.
Furthermore, both the analytical and numerical results agree and are primarily within
the expected lab-to-lab variability of 18% documented in ASTM D1596 - Standard
Test Method for Dynamic Shock Cushioning Characteristics of Packaging Material.
KEYWORDS
cushion curve, nonlinear dynamics, packaging, polymer foam, shock pulse
1 INTRODUCTION
A wide range of packaged products types are susceptible to damage as
a result of shock loading. The loading can be due to mishandling during
transport, or a transient loading condition caused by the transportation
environment, i.e., bumps in the road for truck travel or turbulence for
air travel. The shock attenuation properties of a cushion material are
experimentally determined using ASTM D1596 Standard Test Method
for Shocking Absorbing Characteristics of Package Cushioning Materials.
1
In the test, a mass M is dropped from a height H on a sample cushioning
material of area A. The goal of the test is to study the effect of the
static stress
s
= Mg∕A and drop height on the peak deacceleration of
the mass as the foam is compressed. The results are represented as
cushion curves that plot peak acceleration during impact versus static
stress.
2
Mathematical models of impact response of packaging systems orig-
inated in the 1990s.
3-7
These modelling efforts significantly reduced
the necessary time to determine cushion curves from the experimen-
tal procedures outlined in ASTM D1596.
8
Initially, the mathematical
predictions were based on an energy balance during impact
2,3,5-7,9-11
and evolved to both analytical solutions and numerical simulations
of the impact process.
12-17
However, with the exception of finite
element simulations,
14,18
these efforts were based on a lumped param-
eter approximation of the cushioning foam and impacting mass. The
key to these modelling efforts is to capture both the dissipative and
quasi-static stress strain behaviour of the material. While not directly
related to foam
19-21
noted that the initial quasi-static constitutive
behaviour in corrugated boxes is similar to foam, and thus, the boxes
should offer similar shock absorption properties.
This study aims to provide a rigorous analysis beyond the lumped
parameter paradigm on the prediction of shock response of cush-
ioned materials. The materials used in this study are an expanded
polystyrene foam EPS20,
22
Styropor
23
(BASF), and a polyethylene
foam, Ethafoam 150 (Nova Chemicals). Like other expanded polymer
Packag Technol Sci. 2019;1–12. wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/pts © 2019 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. 1