Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Land Use Policy
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/landusepol
Environmental discounting behaviour of smallholder farmers in Chibombo
District, Central Zambia
Fiona Chisanga Mubanga*, Bridget Bwalya Umar
Department of Geography and Environmental Studies, School of Natural Sciences, University of Zambia, P. O. Box 32379 Lusaka, Zambia
ARTICLE INFO
Keywords:
Agroforestry
Soil conservation
Time preference
Risk aversion
Low adoption
ABSTRACT
This study utilised 158 semi structured interviews, three focus group discussions and two key informant inter-
views to achieve its aim of investigating environmental discounting by smallholder farmers in Chibombo,
Zambia. Results suggest that most smallholder farmers were willing to continue using mineral fertilisers in the
short to medium term even when they were told there could be potentially negative effects as a result. This result
was attributed to the farmers’ experience with neutralising soil acidity through lime application and crop ro-
tations. The proportions of smallholder farmers who would continue using pesticides increased with the period it
takes for pesticide induced soil infertility to manifest. The respondents seemed more concerned about effects on
the soil that would manifest in five years. Smallholder farmers preferred soil improving practices with short term
benefits, and low risk. The proportions of smallholder farmers willing to plant fertiliser trees reduced from 68.5
% when the benefits accrue in five years to about 38 % when said benefits accrue to the next generation. Study
recommends that agricultural development interventions should focus on low risk, locally available technologies
with shorter term benefits and minimal future costs. Study recommends that agricultural development inter-
ventions include innovation of practices with shorter term benefits, minimal future costs and farmer sensitisation
on the benefits of sustainable agriculture.
1. Introduction
Land degradation currently affects 40 % of global agricultural land
with an estimated cost to agriculture of US$ 500 billion per annum
(Pacheco et al., 2018). The environmental consequences of degradation
that have impacted agriculture globally are soil erosion and soil nu-
trient losses. In sub-Saharan Africa, land degradation is associated with
poor soil fertility management practices (Zingore et al., 2015; Nkoye
et al., 2016). Agricultural land is degraded due to low nutrient appli-
cation, soil erosion and soil acidification (Zingore et al., 2015). It is
estimated that soil nutrient depletion causes a 7% reduction of the
agricultural share to the average Gross Domestic Product of Sub-Sa-
haran Africa, with national values ranging upwards of 25 % (Drechsel
et al., 2001). This shows the impact of soil nutrient mining on economic
performance (Drechsel et al., 2001). As a region where the majority of
inhabitants are poor, living in rural areas and depending on natural
resources to sustain livelihoods, countries in Sub-Saharan Africa have
formulated a number of policies and strategies to address land de-
gradation and to enhance agricultural productivity (Nkoye et al., 2016).
These include the promotion of Sustainable Land Management (SLM)
practices.
Sustainable Land Management is the adoption of land use systems
that enable land users to maximise the economic and social benefits
from the land while maintaining or enhancing the ecological support
functions of the land resource (Liniger et al., 2011). SLM practices in-
clude those that: minimize soil erosion and leaching (e.g. permanent
soil cover, mulching); recycle organic nutrients by retaining all crop
residues on the field of origin; enhance biological sources of nutrients
through practices such as agroforestry; compensate for nutrient loss
through the addition of organic or mineral fertilizer; and use adapted
and efficient species of crops to enhance yield (World Bank, 2006). By
adopting SLM practices such as agroforestry, resource-constrained
smallholder farmers can maintain soil fertility better than with mineral
fertiliser. Unlike mineral fertiliser that has been reported to result in
soil acidity after prolonged use (Bune-mann and McNeill, 2004),
agroforestry has been eulogised as a cost effective and sustainable way
of maintaining soil fertility. Overall, the adoption of sustainable agri-
cultural practices can result in soil fertility increase and concomitant
crop yield increase, food security and household incomes (Nkomoki
et al., 2018).
Despite the extensive promotion of SLM among smallholder farmers
in Sub-Saharan Africa, adoption of SLM practices among the farmers
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol.2020.104551
Received 26 February 2019; Received in revised form 2 January 2020; Accepted 26 February 2020
⁎
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: chisanga22@gmail.com (F.C. Mubanga).
Land Use Policy 95 (2020) 104551
Available online 21 March 2020
0264-8377/ © 2020 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
T