MIDCONTINENTAL JOURNAL OF ARCHAEOLOGY
2024, VOL. 49, NO. 3, xxx–xxx
CONTACT Michael J. Shott shott@uakron.edu
© 2024 Midwest Archaeological Conference
ABSTRACT
The Central Ohio Archaeological Digitization Survey (COADS)
documented large samples of precontact artifacts, notably
points, held by private collectors in south-central Ohio, in
the United States. COADS captured two-dimensional images
of several thousand points and several hundred three-
dimensional images. Subjects were processed for landmark-
based geometric morphometric (LGM) analysis as entire points
and as stems only. Among other things, analysis can test for
resharpening allometry—the possibility that preferential
resharpening of blades caused change in shape with change
in size of points—and related LGM concepts of modularity
and integration. This study reports analysis for allometry in
early Holocene COADS Thebes and St. Charles points. A clear
allometric signal with fairly high modularity resides in the
data; blade shape much more than stem shape varies with size,
corroborated by independent reduction measures. Separate
analysis of stems alone indicated no allometry, as expected
since stems vary little with resharpening. Allometry must be
considered before attributing variation in midcontinental
whole-point shape to adaptation, drift, or other mechanisms.
KEYWORDS
Thebes points; allometry;
modularity; Ohio;
reduction; morphometrics
Projectile points are a common subject of North American archaeological study.
Befitting their popularity, points are informative in many ways. Types mark inter-
vals of past time, register activity by their inferred function, and may distinguish
social or cultural groups. Their distributions reflect the distribution of populations
or cultural groups. Points are superabundant and, in contrast to constructed units
like “site,” possess a natural integrity; apart from the breakage many of them ex-
perienced, points are integral wholes in the limited sense that their recognition
and description require no chain of inference, sometimes elaborate, as do “sites,”
“cultures,” and other synthetic units. This is merely to acknowledge that points are
real things, irreducible units of observation.
Morphometric Analysis of Allometry and Modularity
in Early Holocene Thebes and St. Charles Points of
Midcontinental North America
Michael J. Shott,
a
Kevin C. Nolan,
b
and Eric Olson
c
a
Department of Anthropology, University of Akron, Akron, OH 44325;
b
Applied Anthropology Lab-
oratories, Cooper Science, Rm 221C, Ball State University Muncie, IN 47306;
c
Cuyahoga Community
College, 11000 West Pleasant Valley Road, Parma, OH 44130
MCJA 49_3 Shott.indd 1 MCJA 49_3 Shott.indd 1 8/8/24 2:28 PM 8/8/24 2:28 PM