Engineering Analysis with Boundary Elements 104 (2019) 170–182
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Engineering Analysis with Boundary Elements
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/enganabound
Fictitious eigenfrequencies in the BEM for interior acoustic problems
Chang-Jun Zheng
a,∗
, Chuan-Xing Bi
a
, Chuanzeng Zhang
b
, Yong-Bin Zhang
a
, Hai-Bo Chen
c
a
Institute of Sound and Vibration Research, Hefei University of Technology, Hefei, Anhui, 230009, PR China
b
Department of Civil Engineering, University of Siegen, Siegen, D-57068, Germany
c
CAS Key Laboratory of Mechanical Behavior and Design of Materials, Department of Modern Mechanics, University of Science and Technology of China, Hefei, Anhui,
230027, PR China
a r t i c l e i n f o
Keywords:
Boundary element method
Fictitious eigenfrequencies
Interior acoustic problems
Burton–Miller formulation
Nonlinear eigenvalue problems
a b s t r a c t
It is widely known that the boundary element method (BEM) without any special treatment suffers from the ficti-
tious eigenfrequency problem for the numerical solutions of exterior acoustic problems. This problem has drawn
much attention and been extensively studied over the last several decades. However, this paper is concerned with
the existence and influence of the fictitious eigenfrequencies when using the BEM for the numerical solutions of
interior acoustic problems. To this end, an eigenvalue analysis technique is developed for the acoustic BEM. The
nonlinear eigenvalue problem caused by the acoustic BEM is converted into an ordinary linear one by using a
contour integral method. Therefore, the conversion is fulfilled by solving a series of BEM systems of equations
without any special or complicated treatment of the governing equations or the linear systems. Three interior
acoustic examples including two with simply connected domains and one with a multiply connected domain
are used to reveal the existence and influence of the fictitious eigenfrequencies. Furthermore, the Burton–Miller
formulation with a variable coupling parameter is found to be able to remove such fictitious eigenfrequencies,
and the optimal choice of the coupling parameter is investigated.
1. Introduction
The boundary element method (BEM), sometimes also called
the boundary integral equation method (BIEM), is one of the major
numerical techniques for solving partial differential equations of a
variety of physical problems. In this method, the partial differential
equation (PDE) is first transformed into a boundary integral equation
(BIE) defined over the surfaces enclosing the problem domain. The
BIE is then solved by discretizing the surfaces into small patches, or
more exactly, boundary elements. In comparison with other numerical
techniques based on the domain discretization, e.g., the finite element
method (FEM), the BEM has some special features [1,2]. One of the
most remarkable features is that it can deal with unbounded domains
rigorously without any approximation or truncation of the domains.
This unique feature enables us to solve the wave propagation problems
[3–10], e.g., acoustic [4–7], elastodynamic [8,9] and electromagnetic
problems [10], in unbounded domains with high accuracy. However,
some inherent shortcomings also exist. A well-known one is that,
although the solution to the original PDE with adequate boundary con-
ditions is unique, the transformed BIE fails to yield a unique solution
at certain frequencies for exterior wave propagation problems [11,12].
These frequencies correspond to the resonant frequencies of the associ-
∗
Corresponding author.
E-mail addresses: cjzheng@hfut.edu.cn (C.-J. Zheng), cxbi@hfut.edu.cn (C.-X. Bi), c.zhang@uni-siegen.de (C. Zhang), ybzhang@hfut.edu.cn (Y.-B. Zhang),
hbchen@ustc.edu.cn (H.-B. Chen).
ated interior problems and are often called fictitious eigenfrequencies
since they have no physical meaning, but just arise from the drawback
of the BIE to solving exterior wave propagation problems.
The fictitious eigenfrequency phenomenon of the Kirchhof–
Helmholtz integral equation when solving exterior acoustic problems
has been extensively studied in the past decades, see for example
[13–15] for frequency-domain problems and [16] for time-domain
problems. Two methods appropriate for practical applications have
been widely used to circumvent the fictitious eigenfrequency problem.
One is the combined Helmholtz integral equation formulation (CHIEF)
[11] which can tackle the problem by adding additional constraints
at some internal points. This method is very simple to implement but
the determination of appropriate number and positions of the internal
points may become troublesome as the frequency increases [15,17]. The
other approach to circumvent the fictitious eigenfrequency problem is
the Burton–Miller formulation [12] which uses a linear combination of
the Kirchhoff–Helmholtz integral equation and its normal derivative.
It has been proved mathematically that such a linear combination pro-
vides unique solutions at all frequencies, provided that the imaginary
part of the coupling parameter is nonzero [12]. The advantage of this
method is that there is no necessity to make the annoying choice of
internal points. The main difficulty is that the normal derivative BIE
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enganabound.2019.03.042
Received 6 November 2018; Received in revised form 22 February 2019; Accepted 31 March 2019
0955-7997/© 2019 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.