Geoarchaeology
REVIEW ARTICLE
The Mediterranean Valleys Revisited
John Bintliff
Archaeology Department, Edinburgh University, Edinburgh, UK
Correspondence: John Bintliff (johnlbintliff@gmail.com)
Received: 24 June 2024 | Revised: 29 October 2024 | Accepted: 1 November 2024
Scientific Editor: Kevin Walsh
Keywords: alluviation | climate change | erosion | human impact | Mediterranean | sea level
ABSTRACT
The publication of The Mediterranean Valleys by Claudio Vita‐Finzi in 1969 produced a radical change in research perspectives
for our understanding of the timing and causation of erosional and depositional sequences in this macro‐region. This article will
trace the debates that arose from this book and outline our current understanding of the interaction between human impact,
short‐ and long‐term climatic fluctuations and landscape variability in moulding the development of Mediterranean surface
landforms during the Holocene era.
1 | Introduction—Vita‐Finzi's Legacy
The Mediterranean region possesses a climate, traditional land
use and geology, which makes it one of the Earth's landscape
zones most prone to erosion (Lewin, Macklin, and Woodward
1995, Introduction). Since Antiquity and into the present day, it
has been, and still is, commonly accepted that the removal of
soil, the levelling of hillslopes for land use and construction and
the infill of coastal bays by prograding river deltas have been a
continuous process, and one in which human impact was the
prime cause (cf. Plato, Critias 110–111, Attenborough 1987,
Hughes 2015).
Then, in 1969, a remarkable, slim volume appeared from
Cambridge University Press that would change everything in
the scientific study of Mediterranean landscape change. An
outgrowth from his doctoral research, Claudio Vita‐Finzi's
monograph, The Mediterranean Valleys, introduced a very dif-
ferent story (Vita‐Finzi 1969). Widespread landscape transfor-
mation resulting in major alluvial infills of Mediterranean
valley systems was far from being continuous; rather, he iden-
tified just two major episodes of significant alluviation. One was
the consequence of very different climatic conditions to the
present during the last Ice Age, the Older Fill, and the other,
dating from Late Antiquity, the Younger Fill, he believed was
likewise climatically induced, the effect of an unusual climate
during Late Roman times. In this volume and other publica-
tions (e.g., Vita‐Finzi 1978, 2010), he has subsequently allowed
that locally, there have occurred additional alluvial aggradation
phases due to tectonics, human disturbance and other factors,
but on a wider scale, only these two major episodes were
identified in his original monograph as Mediterranean‐wide.
In 1970, as an undergraduate, Eric Higgs invited me to partic-
ipate in a Cambridge University archaeological expedition to
Israel. In the framework of his innovative Palaeoeconomy
movement, this project was focussed on collecting seed and
bone remains from current excavations and carrying out the
newly created landscape archaeology evaluation approach that
Higgs had invented with Claudio, Site Catchment Analysis
(Vita‐Finzi et al. 1970). One of my student tasks, and easily the
most exciting, was to accompany Claudio in creating catchment
studies of several prehistoric sites. This involved walking out
from the site and mapping land use potential up to an hour or
two on foot, the aim being to suggest which local factors led the
site to be occupied and what resources could be extracted
within its immediately accessible territory (Figure 1).
Claudio was bronzed, athletic and extremely charismatic
(Figure 2). At one point, he abruptly stopped the jeep that he
© 2024 Wiley Periodicals LLC.
1 of 8 Geoarchaeology, 2024; 40:e22029
https://doi.org/10.1002/gea.22029