1 Bryant M, et al. BMJ Open 2024;14:e081861. doi:10.1136/bmjopen-2023-081861
Open access
Effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of a
sustainable obesity prevention
programme for preschool children
delivered at scale ‘HENRY’ (Health,
Exercise, Nutrition for the Really
Young): protocol for the HENRY III
cluster randomised controlled trial
Maria Bryant ,
1,2
Wendy Burton,
2
Michelle Collinson,
3
Adam Martin,
4
Bethan Copsey ,
3
Dawn Groves-Williams ,
3
Alexis Foster ,
5
Thomas A Willis,
6
Philip Garnett,
7
Alicia O'Cathain
5
To cite: Bryant M, Burton W,
Collinson M, et al. Effectiveness
and cost-effectiveness
of a sustainable obesity
prevention programme for
preschool children delivered
at scale ‘HENRY’ (Health,
Exercise, Nutrition for the
Really Young): protocol for the
HENRY III cluster randomised
controlled trial. BMJ Open
2024;14:e081861. doi:10.1136/
bmjopen-2023-081861
► Prepublication history
and additional supplemental
material for this paper are
available online. To view these
files, please visit the journal
online (https://doi.org/10.1136/
bmjopen-2023-081861).
Received 09 November 2023
Accepted 04 March 2024
For numbered affiliations see
end of article.
Correspondence to
Professor Maria Bryant;
maria.bryant@york.ac.uk
Protocol
© Author(s) (or their
employer(s)) 2024. Re-use
permitted under CC BY.
Published by BMJ.
ABSTRACT
Introduction One-fifth of children start school
already overweight or living with obesity, with rates
disproportionately impacting those living in the most
deprived areas. Social, environmental and biological
factors contribute to excess weight gain and programmes
delivered in early years settings aim to support families
to navigate these in order to prevent obesity. One of
these programmes (Health, Exercise and Nutrition for
the Really Young, HENRY) has been delivered in UK
community venues (hereon named ‘centres’) in high
deprivation areas since 2008 and aims to help families
to provide a healthy start for their preschool children. We
aim to establish the effectiveness and cost-effectiveness
of HENRY, including its potential role from a wider
systems perspective.
Methods and analysis This is a multicentre, open-
labelled, two-group, prospective, cluster randomised
controlled trial, with cost-effectiveness analysis,
systems-based process evaluation and internal pilot.
Primary analysis will compare body mass index (BMI)
z-score at 12 months in children (n=984) whose parents
have attended HENRY to those who have not attended.
Secondary outcomes include parent and staff BMI and
waist circumference, parenting efficacy, feeding, eating
habits, quality of life, resource use and medium term (3
years) BMI z-scores (child and siblings). 82 centres in ~14
local authority areas will be randomised (1:1) to receive
HENRY or continue with standard practice. Intention-to-
treat analysis will compare outcomes using mixed effects
linear regression. Economic evaluation will estimate a
within-trial calculation of cost-per unit change in BMI z-
score and longer-term trajectories to determine lifelong
cost savings (long-term outcomes). A systems process
evaluation will explore whether (and how) implementation
of HENRY impacts (and is impacted by) the early years
obesity system. An established parent advisory group will
support delivery and dissemination.
Ethics and dissemination Ethical approval has been
granted by the University of York, Health Sciences’
Research Governance Committee (HSRGC/2022/537/E).
Dissemination includes policy reports, community
resources, social media and academic outputs.
Trial registration number ISRCTN16529380.
INTRODUCTION
Reducing the prevalence of childhood
obesity among people living in deprived
areas is a public policy priority. Approx-
imately one- third of children (27.7%
on average and up to 34.5% in higher
STRENGTHS AND LIMITATIONS OF THIS STUDY
⇒ The Health, Exercise and Nutrition for the Really
Young (HENRY) III trial provides an opportunity to
examine the effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of
an intervention that has been publicly funded and
delivered at scale for more than 10 years, including
short-term, medium-term and long-term outcomes.
⇒ Our systems-based process evaluation will explore
the role that community-based obesity prevention
interventions play within the wider system, based on
the understanding that factors that influence obesity
are complex and multifaceted.
⇒ The HENRY III trial has been designed following a
successful feasibility study, in collaboration with lo-
cal and national government partners, members of
the public and a multidisciplinary trial team.
⇒ The trial’s success is dependent on recruitment of
local authority areas, where additional funding will
be required to commission the intervention.
⇒ A mitigation strategy has been developed to reduce
the risk of selection bias inherent in cluster designs.
on July 24, 2024 by guest. Protected by copyright. http://bmjopen.bmj.com/ BMJ Open: first published as 10.1136/bmjopen-2023-081861 on 25 March 2024. Downloaded from