AN INVESTMENT PREFERENCE UNDER INCOMPLETE DATA
I. Popchev and I. Radeva
Institute of Information Technologies
Akad Georgy Bonchev str., bl. 2
1113 Sofia, Bulgaria
Tel.: (+359 2) 716851, Fax: (+359 2) 9434589
Email: iradeva@iit.bas.bg
Abstract: The presented approach uses contradictory results of different multi-
discriminant bankruptcy prediction models, applied to a sample of Bulgarian public
companies. It allows the application of an expert classification of the sample
investigated. Conditions are provided for discriminant analysis appliance, through a
grouping variable based on an expert decision and named Investment Preference.
The approach presented enables an analysis of the Investment Preference under
conditions of incomplete data. Copyright © 2004 IFAC
Keywords: Economics, Incomplete data, Evaluation, Decision making, Discriminant
analysis, Iterative method
1. INTRODUCTION
1
The techniques based on fundamental and technical
analysis are widely applied in investment decision
making on capital markets. The technical analysis on
Bulgarian market, although already applied turned
out to be not quite effective as it is not liquid enough,
the market capitalization is low and free floats of
listed companies are few. The fundamental analysis
is accepted as a preferred technique, but it is costly
and hardly affordable for individual investors.
Alternatively, the financial ratios analysis mɚy be
used as the input data to perform it are accessible and
many software programs offer its calculation.
The bankruptcy prediction modeling is also an
acceptable tool for investment decision making. This
field is widely discussed in economics literature.
Three basic techniques are used for developing
bankruptcy prediction models (BPMs): Discriminant
analysis (DA), artificial neural networks (ANN), and
1
This work is supported by the National Science Fund of
the Bulgarian Ministry of Education and Science under
grand No. I1305/2003
fuzzy sets (FS). Regarded pioneers in developing
models based on DA are Beaver, Altman ɢ Ohlson.
Bankruptcy prediction based on ANNs begins at 90’s
of the 20
-th
century and marks a rapid development
(Atiya, 2001). Ⱥs a whole, the ANN models’
classification accuracy is comparable with that of the
Multivariate DA models. The latest techniques
applied in bankruptcy prediction modeling are FS.
Each of the techniques afore mentioned has its
advantages and shortcomings. Anyway, DA remains
the leader with respect to range of applicability
(Shirata, 1998). Therefore, in this paper, DA was the
preferred techniques to achieve the objectives of this
study.
The objectives are:
1. To verify an applicability of some known
BPMs over a sample of Bulgarian companies.
2. To develop an approach for expert
classification of public companies under
conditions of incomplete data.
3. To apply DA for verification of the expert
classification in point 2 and for actualizing of
this classification.
IFAC DECOM-TT 2004
Automatic Systems for Building the Infrastructure in Developing Countries
October 3 - 5, 2004 Bansko, Bulgaria