First detection of etoxazole resistance in Australian two-spotted mite
Tetranychus urticae Koch (Acarina: Tetranychidae) via bioassay and DNA
methods
Grant A Herron,* Lauren K Woolley, Kate L Langfield and Yizhou Chen
New South Wales Department of Primary Industries, Elizabeth Macarthur Agricultural Institute, Private Bag 4008, Narellan,
2567, Australia.
Abstract Etoxazole is used in Australia to control mites on a range of crops including pome fruit and cotton. Although
resistance has been widely reported elsewhere, it has not previously been detected in Australia. Here, we report
the first detection of etoxazole resistance (>12 500 fold) in Australian two-spotted mite Tetranychus urticae from
pome fruit via both bioassay and DNA methods. It is envisaged that the DNA-based method developed here can be
used to monitor etoxazole resistance in T. urticae.
Key words bioassay, PCR-restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP), resistance detection, resistance management.
INTRODUCTION
Etoxazole was first registered for use in Australia in 2004 by
Sumitomo Chemical Australia Pty Limited for spider mite
control (mainly Tetranychus spp.) on a range of crops including
horticulture and broad acre (APVMA 2016). Etoxazole belongs
to the Insecticide Resistance Action Committee (IRAC) mode of
action (MOA) group 10B known as mite insect growth inhibitors
of unknown or uncharacterised biological activity (IRAC 2016).
Etoxazole does not affect adults directly but causes them to
produce unviable eggs (Kim & Yoo 2002; Dekeyser 2005;
Nauen & Smagghe 2006). Furthermore, etoxazole disrupts the
moulting process of mite juvenile stages (Yoo & Kim 2000).
Etoxazole resistance in Tetranychus urticae has been reported
in Japan (Kobayashi et al. 2001; Uesugi et al. 2002; Asahara
et al. 2008) and South Korea (Lee et al. 2004), but not in
Australia. Resistance is thought under the control of a single
(Kobayashi et al. 2001) autosomal recessive (van Leeuwen
et al. 2012) gene. The I1017F mutation found within the
last transmembrane helix of the predicted C-terminal 5
transmembrane domain of chitin synthase (CHS1) was linked
to etoxazole resistance in T. urticae (van Leeuwen et al. 2012).
Recently, a genome-editing approach whereby the I1017F
mutation was introduced into the Drosophila melanogaster
CHS1 gene (kkv) provided functional evidence for a target-site
mutation in etoxazole resistance (Douris et al. 2016).
Herron (2005) established bioassay methodology for
etoxazole against T. urticae and a discriminating dose for use
in Australian cotton, but the product was not heavily used, and
resistance monitoring was not conducted. However, recent data
from Australian cotton suggest that resistance frequencies
against key chemical controls may compromise efficacy and
resistance to abamectin is increasing (Herron & Wilson 2016).
For that reason, etoxazole use in Australian cotton may increase,
and monitoring would again be a priority. Woolley et al. (2015)
recently discovered the etoxazole resistance causing mutation
I1017F in an Australian isolate of T. urticae, but the result was
not considered unequivocal as no bioassay data was available
for confirmation.
Here, we corroborate the result of Woolley et al. (2015)
against established bioassay methodology to unequivocally
confirm etoxazole resistance in Australian T. urticae for the
first time and provide a verified DNA-based method for
resistance monitoring.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Acaricide
Supplied by Sumitomo Chemical Australia Pty Limited as
Paramite® or Zeal® Selective Miticide (110 g/L etoxazole
suspension concentrate) that is field sprayed (pome and stone
fruit) at 35 mL product/100 L.
Strains tested
The reference susceptible strain was collected from an unsprayed
ornamental crop in the Sydney region in 1988; it has been
isolated since collection and is known to be susceptible (Herron
et al. 2004). The field isolate ‘Nashee
f
’ was collected in 2015
from a commercial fruit crop at Banbartha, New South Wales
with unknown spray history. Cultures were maintained under
insecticide-free conditions in separate, purpose-built cages on
potted French bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) at 25°C (± 4°C)
under natural light and transferred onto a fresh plant weekly
(Herron et al. 2004). A sub strain of ‘Nashee
f
’ known as
‘Nashee
p
’ was sprayed with a 0.001 g/L etoxazole
discriminating dose (Herron 2005) on an ad hoc basis to
maintain resistance. *grant.herron@dpi.nsw.gov.au
© 2017 State of New South Wales doi: 10.1111/aen.12290
Austral Entomology (2017) ••, ••–••
bs_bs_banner