Cell, Vol. 81,317-318, May 5, 1995, Copyright © 1995 by Cell Press
Obituary
Harold Weintraub (1945-1995)
Hal Weintraub died on March 28, 1995, at the age of 49.
Acreative intellect, he contributed profoundly to our under-
standing of the molecular biology of development. From
his early work on the structure of the eucaryotic chromo-
some to the recent identification of genes capable of etic-
iting an entire program of cellular differentiation, Hal re-
peatedly identified important problems in biology and
solved them in an elegant fashion. For those fortunate
enough to have shared Hal's enthusiasm for science or to
have been touched by his humanity, his premature death is
an immeasurable loss.
Hal Weintraub grew up playing baseball and basketball
on the streets of Newark. He began his training in science
as an undergraduate at Harvard College and received
M.D. and Ph.D. degrees from the University of Pennsylva-
nia, working in the laboratory of Howard Holtzer. As a
Ph.D. student in the early 1970s, Hal became intrigued
by the problem of how the regulation of gene expression
during development leads to the differentiation of specific
cell types. Insight into the molecular mechanisms of gene
control had only recently emerged for a few phage and
bacterial genes. Despite the complexity of mammalian de-
velopment, Hal initiated a bold effort to understand the
relationship between the structure of eukaryotic genes in
the chromosome and the regulation of their expression
during development.
Experiments initiated at the Medical Research Council
in Cambridge, England, when Hal was a fellow with Sidney
Brenner and Francis Crick, showed that nucleosomes re-
side on active genes in the chromosome, but that the
nucleosomal structure is altered when the gene is tran-
scribed. At Princeton University and later at the Fred
Hutchinson Cancer Center, Hal used the globin gene clus-
ters as a model system to define the concept of a transcrip-
tionally active chromosomal domain. The globin gene do-
mains contain the cluster of developmentally regulated
globin genes and tens of thousands of base pairs of DNA
on either side. The entire domain exhibited enhanced sen-
sitivity to nuclease in erythroid cells, and discrete sites of
hypersensitivity appeared adjacent to the individual genes
as they were sequentially activated during development.
This work established an important relationship between
gene activity and chromosome structure.
In the early 1980s Hal began to think about the problem
of identifying genes central to embryonic development in
vertebrates. Recognizing the difficulty in obtaining useful
developmental mutants in vertebrates, Hal introduced the
idea of using antisense RNA to elicit specific mutant phe-
notypes. This approach, in which a complementary strand
of mRNA is expressed in cells or embryos to inhibit the
expression of specific mRNAs, allows the generation of
lack-of-function phenotypes and permits the assessment
of the role of specific genes in development in the absence
of classical developmental genetics.
More recently, in a remarkable series of experiments,
Hal identified a single gene, myoD, which can elicit the
entire prog'ram of muscle differentiation when introduced
into nonmuscle cell types. He demonstrated that muscle
cell differentiation could be elicited in fibroblasts following
the transfer of genomic DNA from muscle cells. This led
Hal to the isolation of the myoD gene, which encodes a
transcriptional activator that promotes myogenesis by di-
rectly binding to a control region shared by muscle-specific
genes. Moreover, MyoD activates its own transcription,
creating an autoregulatory loop that stabilizes the commit-
ment to myogenesis. Structure-function analysis allowed
the definition of a complex set of interactions between
MyoD and distinct heterodimer partners to generate either
positive or negative regulatory proteins.
Hal Weintraub and his colleagues pioneered virtually
every stage in the discovery and elucidation of the function
of MyoD, from its structure, to the mechanism it uses to
activate the myogenic program, to how MyoD itself is tran-
scriptionally and posttranscriptionally regulated during de-
velopment. These experiments led to the notion of myoD
and its homologs as regulatory genes that together play
central roles in the flow of myogenic information from the
early embryo to the mature myofibril, a concept of general
importance in cellular differentiation.
This brief summary of Hal's accomplishments, however,
does not adequately portray his unique approach to biol-
ogy. His efforts were driven by a creative intuition coupled
with a courage to explore his ideas experimentally. One of
his greatest strengths was his ability to conceive of simple
experimental approaches that led to major advances in
our understanding of complex biological phenomenon. His
scientific persona was characterized by an odd mix of na-
ivete and confidence that led him in directions where oth-
ers feared to venture.
The breadth and intensity of Hal's interest in science
was strongly felt, not only by his students and fellows, but
by an entire community of biologists. He listened to the
efforts of others with excitement and contributed his
thoughts and ideas generously. Despite Hal's gentle and
soft spoken manner and his aversion to the politics of ad-
ministration, he brought together an exciting group of
young scientists to create an exceptional research organi-
zation at the Fred Hutchinson Cancer Center.
Hal was sustained through his brief but courageous bat-
tle with brain cancer by a close relationship with his wife
Nancy and his sons, Adam and Joshua, and by the devo-
tion of his collaborator and friend, Mark Groudine. During
his illness, science remained a source of great comfort.
On the morning of his brain surgery, he phoned one of
us, wanting to talk while waiting to be taken to the op-