Damage control surgery in weightlessness: A comparative
study of simulated torso hemorrhage control comparing
terrestrial and weightless conditions
Andrew W. Kirkpatrick, MD, MHSC, Jessica Lynn McKee, MSc, Homer Tien, MD, Anthony J. LaPorta, MD,
Kit Lavell, Tim Leslie, MSc, David R. King, MD, Paul B. McBeth, MD, Susan Brien, MD,
Derek J. Roberts, MD, PhD, Reginald Franciose, MD, Jonathan Wong, Vivian McAlistair, MD,
Danielle Bouchard, and Chad G. Ball, MD, MSC, Alberta, Canada
BACKGROUND: Torso bleeding remains the most preventable cause of post-traumatic death worldwide. Remote damage control resuscitation (RDCR) en-
deavours to rescue the most catastrophically injured, but has not focused on prehospital surgical torso hemorrhage control (HC). We exam-
ined the logistics and metrics of intraperitoneal packing in weightlessness in Parabolic flight (0g) compared to terrestrial gravity (1g) as an
extreme example of surgical RDCR.
METHODS: A surgical simulator was customized with high-fidelity intraperitoneal anatomy, a “blood” pump and flowmeter. A standardized HC task
was to explore the simulator, identify “bleeding” from a previously unknown liver injury perfused at 80 mm Hg, and pack to gain hemo-
stasis. Ten surgeons performed RDCR laparotomies onboard a research aircraft, first in 1g followed by 0g. The standardized laparotomy
was sectioned into 20-second segments to conduct and facilitate parabolic flight comparisons, with “blood” pumped only during these time
segments. A maximum of 12 segments permitted for each laparotomy.
RESULTS: All 10 surgeons successfully performed HC in both 1g and 0g. There was no difference in blood loss between 1g and 0g (p = 0.161) or
during observation following HC (p = 0.944). Compared to 1g, identification of bleeding in 0g incurred less “blood” loss (p = 0.032). Over-
all surgeons rated their personal performance and relative difficulty of surgery in 0g as “harder” (median Likert, 2/5). However, conducting
all phases of HC were rated equivalent between 1g and 0g (median Likert, 3/5), except for instrument control (rated slightly harder, 2.75/5).
CONCLUSION: Performing laparotomies with packing of a simulated torso hemorrhage in a high-fidelity surgical simulator was feasible onboard a research
aircraft in both normal and weightless conditions. Despite being subjectively “harder,” most phases of operative intervention were rated
equivalently, with no statistical difference in “blood” loss in weightlessness. Direct operative control of torso hemorrhage is theoretically
possible in extreme environments if logistics are provided. (J Trauma Acute Care Surg. 2017;82: 392–399. Copyright © 2016 Wolters
Kluwer Health, Inc. All rights reserved.)
KEY WORDS: Exsanguination; operational medicine; tactical medicine; telemedicine; damage control surgery; surgical simulation.
W
hether building a space habitat or engaging in military
operations, in a hostile location, far from any established
hospital, exsanguination is the most likely potentially treatable
cause of death.
1,2
Eastridge reported that during Operations Iraqi
Freedom and Enduring Freedom, 87% of all battlefield injury
fatalities occurred before arrival at a medical treatment facility.
3
The single most common (67%) cause of potentially survivable
deaths were related to noncompressible torso hemorrhage
(NCTH).
3
Similarly traumatic injury sustained by a deployed
astronaut has been deemed the most probable incident that will
have the largest impact on astronaut health and subsequently
the mission.
4
The ability to control hemorrhage, specifically
torso hemorrhage after traumatic injury in space remains a critical
limitation in astronaut health care. As in battlefield care, space
medicine is conducted in a setting where the crew must continue
its mission autonomously and where there are enormous difficul-
ties with resupply, evacuation, and even communication.
5–7
For
many such reasons, the crew of an Exploratory Class Space
Mission (one leaving low Earth's orbit) will likely face many
of the same challenges dealing with an exsanguinating team
member as a small Special Forces unit.
To date, there has never been more options to ameliorate
torso exsanguination, including the earliest use of blood products
including fresh warm whole blood and other component thera-
pies, junctional compressive devices, tranexamic acid, balloon
Submitted: August 30, 2016, Revised: September 30, 2016, Accepted: October 4, 2016,
Published online: October 25, 2016.
From the Canadian Forces Health Services (A.W.K., J.W., V.M.A.); Departments of
Surgery (A.W.K., P.B.M.B., D.J.R., C.G.B.), Critical Care Medicine (A.W.K.,
P.B.M.B), the Regional Trauma Services (A.W.K., P.B.M.B, C.G.B.), Foothills
Medical Centre; University of Calgary (A.W.K., P.B.M.B, D.J.R., D.B., C.G.B.),
Calgary, Alberta; Innovative Trauma Care (J.L.M.), Edmonton, Alberta; Sunnybrook
Health Sciences Centre (C.H.T.), Toronto, Ontario, Canada; Rocky Vista (A.J.L.P.),
University School of Medicine, Parker, Colorado; Strategic Operations (K.L.),
San Diego, California; Flight Research Laboratory (T.L.), National Research Council
of Canada, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada; Harvard Medical School (D.R.K.), Boston,
Massachusetts; Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons (S.B.), Ottawa, Ontario,
Canada; Denver Health (R.F.), Denver, Colorado; Vail Valley Medical Center (R.F.),
Vail, Colorado; and University of Western Ontario (V.M.A.), London, Ontario, Canada.
For the Damage Control Surgery in Austere Environments Research Group (DCSAERG).
Trial Registration: ID ISRCTN/77929274.
Supplemental digital content is available for this article. Direct URL citations appear in
the printed text, and links to the digital files are provided in the HTML text of this
article on the journal’s Web site (www.jtrauma.com).
This study was presented as a quick shot at the 75th annual meeting of the American
Association for the Surgery of Trauma, September 14–17, 2016, in Waikaloa, Hawaii.
Address for reprints: Andrew W. Kirkpatrick, MD, MHSC, EG23 Foothills Medical Centre,
Calgary, Alberta, T2N 2T9 Andrew; email: Andrew.kirkpatrick@albertahealthservices.ca.
DOI: 10.1097/TA.0000000000001310
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
392
J Trauma Acute Care Surg
Volume 82, Number 2
Copyright © 2017 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. All rights reserved.