Abstract A method for the identification and quantifica-
tion of cross-reacting analytes using competitive immuno-
chemical assays is described. The method uses informa-
tion both of antibodies with and without significant inhi-
bition caused by a sample. Maximum concentrations of
all possible analytes were estimated for all antibodies not
showing a significant inhibition. These maximum concen-
trations could be used to exclude certain analytes from the
further identification process. A minimum variance method
was used for the identification of analytes from the data
given by antibodies showing significant inhibition. All
samples were measured in a parallel affinity sensor array
(PASA). The PASA system allows the parallel perfor-
mance of numerous individual immunochemical assays.
Triazines were used as a model substance class. Samples
containing either atrazine, terbuthylazine, simazine or
deethylatrazine at different concentration levels were gen-
erated and analyzed in the PASA system. 11 out of 13
samples were correctly identified, 2 samples could not be
identified without doubt, no wrong identification was ob-
served. Samples of atrazine, terbuthylazine and simazine
at a concentration level of 0.1 μg/L, the EU maximum ad-
missible concentration for individual pesticides, and of
deethylatrazine at 0.3 μg/L could be quantified.
1 Introduction
Immunochemical sensors are a promising tool in environ-
mental analysis. They are often used as fast high-through-
put screening methods. Most immunochemical sensors
show a characteristic lack in selectivity towards cross-re-
acting analytes. Therefore, with many immunochemical
sensors the identification and quantification of a single
compound is not possible and only sum parameters of
structurally related compounds can be obtained.
Many efforts have been made to overcome the problem
of cross-reactivities by means of pattern recognition [1,
2]. Therefore, immunoarrays of different antibodies di-
rected to the same class of analytes have been constructed
on conventional microtiter plates [3, 4]. A drawback of
these arrays is that the number of immunoassays that have
to be performed successively increases with the number
of antibodies forming the array. Hence, additional infor-
mation on a sample is contrary to analysis time and costs.
In order to improve immunoarray performance, auto-
mated immunosensors with multianalyte ability have been
developed [5, 6]. Nevertheless, the described sensor sys-
tems suffer from a lack of scalability concerning the num-
ber of antibodies forming the array.
In order to overcome these problems, we have devel-
oped a parallel affinity sensor array (PASA) for the deter-
mination of cross-reacting analytes, applying a direct as-
say format. Previous results have shown the high scalabil-
ity of the PASA system [7]. Therefore, a PASA is ideally
suited to carry out parallel, automated immunochemical
assays. This paper focuses on the application of the PASA
system on the identification and quantification of triazines
as a model substance class.
We present an improved approach for the identification
and quantification of cross-reacting analytes with im-
munochemical methods. The method is not dependent on
the origin of the experimental data and can be applied to
measurements performed on microtiter plates as well as in
automated sensor systems.
2 Materials and methods
Reagents
MAb 4A54 and MAb K4E7 were purchased from Connex (D-
82152 Martinsried, Germany). MAb 4063-21-1 (21-1) was pro-
vided by Dr. Schlaeppi, Novartis (Basel, Switzerland) and MAb
AM7B2 by Dr. Karu, Immunochemistry Facility, College of Nat-
ural Resources, University of California (Berkeley, USA). All
other reagents were of the highest purity available.
Michael Winklmair · Andreas J. Schuetz ·
Michael G. Weller · Reinhard Niessner
Immunochemical array for the identification of cross-reacting analytes
Fresenius J Anal Chem (1999) 363 : 731–737 © Springer-Verlag 1999
Received: 25 September 1998 / Revised: 30 November 1998 / Accepted: 5 December 1998
CONFERENCE CONTRIBUTION
M. Winklmair · A. J. Schuetz · M. G. Weller () · R. Niessner
Institute of Hydrochemistry, Technical University of Munich,
Marchioninistrasse 17, D-81377 München, Germany
e-mail: michael.weller@ch.tum.de