Delivered by Intellect to:
Copenhagen University Library (cid-2667)
IP: 130.226.236.6
On: Mon, 13 Jan 2025 07:57:18
JSCA 13 (3) pp. 283–300 Intellect Limited 2023
Journal of Scandinavian Cinema
Volume 13 Number 3
www.intellectbooks.com 283
© 2023 Intellect Ltd Feature Article. English language.
https://doi.org/10.1386/jsca_00100_1
Received 15 February 2023; Accepted 5 August 2023; Published Online February 2024
feature article
JOHANNES RIIS
University of Copenhagen
Symbolic purposes of style:
Ruben Östlund’s The Square
ABSTRACT
Symbolic criticism is easily reduced to an act of translating meaning, remote from
the style of rich narratives. Drawing on David Bordwell’s distinction between
broad, overlapping functions of style, I argue that we can examine symbolic
purposes as secondary to decorative and expressive purposes. I show how a theory
on conceptual cognition proposed by psychologist Lawrence Barsalou can let the
critic transcend firm distinctions between abstract and concrete features of a
narrative. This proves especially helpful when narrative purposes are downplayed,
for example in the resonant elements of art cinema, affecting how we construct and
experience the storylines. I posit a framework for the analysis of symbolic purposes
based on general mechanisms of memory and attentional guidance, letting us see
continuity with critics such as Bordwell and Victor F. Perkins. This approach
enables the critic to distinguish between degrees of symbolic power in Ruben
Östlund’s The Square.
David Bordwell’s writings of the 1980s continue to influence how we think
about moving picture narratives, especially his distinction between Hollywood
and art cinema norms (Bordwell 1985a). Reflected in, for example, the degree
to which characters are goal-directed and the story is intelligible or ambigu-
ous, his distinction has inspired scholars to look at art cinema as a category
KEYWORDS
art cinema
film criticism
symbolism
conceptualization
David Bordwell
Victor F. Perkins
Lawrence Barsalou