Citation: Haji MS, Kombo MA, Mohamed AAJ. Quantifying the Levels of Niobium, Copper, Arsenic, Tellurium,
Antimony and Lead in Selected Toothpaste and Lipsticks Samples. Austin Biochem. 2024; 7(1): 1031.
Austin Biochemistry
Volume 7 Issue 1 - 2024
Submit your Manuscript | www.austinpublishinggroup.com
Mohamed AAJ. © All rights are reserved
Austin Biochemistry
Open Access
Abstract
Cosmetics are essential products for many people worldwide because they
help enhance a person’s appearance and boost attractiveness. However, the
only challenge in developing countries is the availability of cosmetics that do
not meet quality standards, which can pose health risks to users. Upon this
study, lipstick samples were found to have high concentration of heavy metals,
which are copper (Cu), Arsenic (As), Tellurium (Te), Niobium (Nb), Antimony
(Sb), and Lead (Pb) at 50.0 ppm, 2.0 ppm, 48.0 ppm, 30.0 ppm, 25.0 ppm, and
7.0 ppm respectively. With respect to toothpastes, three metals that were found
in significant amounts are Cu at 10.0 ppm, Te at 31.0 ppm and Ta at 12.0 ppm.
The level of Antimony (Sb) in lipsticks was found to be higher than the limit
set by World Health Organization (WHO). This can lead to problems such as
skin disease, hormonal disorders, and even cancer. Due to this situation, there
is a need to strengthen regulation and monitoring of cosmetic quality in the
market, as well as to educate consumers on the importance of choosing safe
products for their health. Additionally, cosmetic manufactures should adhere to
international standards to protect the health of consumers.
Keywords: Lipsticks; Toothpaste; Tellurium; Antimony; Arsenic; Niobium
Research Article
Quantifying the Levels of Niobium, Copper, Arsenic,
Tellurium, Antimony and Lead in Selected Toothpaste
and Lipsticks Samples
Mwaka S Haji; Miza A Kombo; Abdul AJ
Mohamed*
Department of Natural Science, School of Natural and
Social Sciences, the State University of Zanzibar. P. O.
Box 146, Zanzibar – Tanzania
*Corresponding author: Abdul AJ Mohamed,
Department of Natural Science, School of Natural and
Social Sciences, the State University of Zanzibar. P. O.
Box 146, Zanzibar – Tanzania.
Email: jumabdull@yahoo.com
Received: November 06, 2024; Accepted: November
28, 2024; Published: December 05, 2024
Introduction
Lipstick is generally made from a blend of waxes, oils, pigments,
and emollients [5]. Typical waxes, such as beeswax, carnauba wax,
and candelilla wax, give the lipstick its structure and firmness [38].
Oils like castor oil, lanolin, and mineral oil ensure smoothness and
even application [14]. Emollients such as shea butter and vitamin E
are included to moisturize and protect the lips [40]. Other pigments,
which include a range of natural and synthetic dyes, give lipstick its
color. Furthermore, lipsticks and toothpaste are cosmetics intended for
application in the oral area, including on the mouth parts, specifically
on lips and teeth [15]. Toothpaste typically contains a combination of
abrasives, fluoride, flavoring agents, and other ingredients that aid in
cleaning, polishing, and freshening breath [34]. Although toothpaste
is mainly used for oral hygiene, it also improves the appearance of
teeth and contributes to a bright, healthy smile. Lipstick is a popular
cosmetic product used to improve the color, texture, and overall
look of the lips [17]. It plays a key role in facial aesthetics and
carries cultural, psychological, and economic importance. Examples
of lipsticks are Matte Lipsticks, Satin and Cream Lipsticks, Gloss
Lipsticks, and Liquid Lipsticks [33].
Toothpaste is a gel or paste used in combination with a toothbrush
to clean and maintain the health of teeth [26]. Its primary functions
are to remove plaque, prevent tooth decay, and reduce gum disease
[20]. As toothpaste is used by both adults and children. Reports show
that children and some adults (pregnant women especially), swallow
a substantial amount of 5 toothpaste in the process of brushing, which
could lead to any of the effects associated to the ingestion of these
substances [16].
Heavy metals are metallic elements with high atomic weights
and densities that are oſten toxic at relatively low concentrations [2].
ey occur naturally in the environment and can also be introduced
through industrial processes, agriculture, and pollution [1]. Some
heavy metals are essential for biological functions in trace amounts,
but excess exposure can lead to serious health problems [21].
e presence of heavy metals in lipsticks and toothpastes is a
significant concern due to their potential health risks [9]. Heavy
metals found in lipsticks and toothpastes may include lead, cadmium,
mercury, and chromium. ese metals can be present as contaminants
in pigments used for coloring or as impurities in raw materials [23].
Even small amounts of lead can accumulate in the body over time
and potentially result in neurological and developmental issues,
particularly in children and pregnant women [35]. Exposure to
cadmium is associated with kidney damage, bone loss, and cancer [8].
Mercury also can affect the kidneys, nervous system, and immune
system, and is particularly harmful when absorbed through the skin
or ingested [41].
Zanzibar has emerged as a significant market for cosmetics,
with numerous products imported from various countries. e