Human Reproduction vol.7 no. 10 pp.1353-1356, 1992
Controlled preparation of the endometrium with
exogenous oestradiol and progesterone: a novel regimen
not using a gonadotrophin-releasing hormone agonist*
Christophe Lelaidier
1
, Dominique de Ziegler,
Jao Gaetano, Andre Hazout, Herv^ Fernandez and
Rene* Frydman
Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, H6pital A.Beclere,
157 rue de la Porte de Trivaux, 92141 Clamart, France
'To whom correspondence should be addressed
In women having inactive ovaries, controlled preparation of
the endometrium has been achieved with exogenous oestradiol
and progesterone. We report on the feasibility and practicality
of using a similar regimen for timing transfers of cryo-
preserved embryos in women whose ovaries have not been
suppressed. A total of 91 women having cryopreserved
embryos from previous in-vitro fertilization (TVF) attempts
received 4 mg/day of oestradiol vakrate, starting on cycle day
1 of spontaneous (n = 85) or induced (n = 6) menstruation.
A single blood sample was obtained on cycle day 14 for the
measurement of plasma progesterone, oestradiol and lutein-
izing hormone (LH). Vaginal administration of mkronized
progesterone (300 mg/day) was started on day 15. Cryo-
preserved embryos were transferred on day 17 or 18 provided
that day 14 plasma progesterone remained ^0.5 ng/ml,
thereby confirming the absence of spontaneous ovulation prior
to the administration of exogenous progesterone. Out of 91
cycles studied, plasma progesterone was found to be elevated
( > 1 ng/ml) in only three (3.2%). Of the 88 scheduled
transfers, 31 did not take place because no embryo survived
thawing. In the remaining 57 cycles, 116 embryos were
transferred resulting in 10 pregnancies, giving pregnancy and
embryo implantation rates of 17.5 and 8.6% respectively.
When a positive ft human chorionk gonadotrophin (HCG)
titre was obtained, supplementation with oral oestradiol and
vaginal progesterone was continued until placenta] autonomy
was achieved. Of the 10 pregnancies, five (50%) were lost
during the first trimester (biochemical, n = 1; miscarriage,
n = 3; ectopic, n = 1). Because the supplementation regimen
is similar to that used successfully in the egg donation
programme, this unusually high incidence of first trimester
pregnancy loss is believed to be coincidental. Yet it cannot
be formally ruled out that the high miscarriage rate did not
result from an inadequate preparation of the endometrium.
When no transfer or no pregnancy occurred, resumption of
menstrua] cycles was prompt after oestradiol and progesterone
treatment was discontinued on day 28. The value of this novel
•Presented at the Society for Gynaecological Investigation (SGI) annual
meeting in San Antonio, TX, USA, March 17-21.
© Oxford University Press
approach for timing transfers of cryopreserved embryos,
involving the controlled preparation of the endometrium with
oestradiol and progesterone, lies in its great clinical simplicity
(only one hormonal sample) and practicality (2-week notice
for scheduling transfers).
Key words: endometrial receptivity/oestradiol valerate/
progesterone
Introduction
Timing transfers of cryopreserved embryos may be problematic
for various practical reasons. In women having irregular
menstrual cycles or luteal phase defect obvious problems occur,
for which complicated solutions have been proposed. In women
having regular menstrual cycles, identifying the pre-ovulatory
luteinizing hormone (LH) surge by semi-quantitative urinary
measurements may fail for purely technical reasons. This often
leads to complicated evaluations of the hormonal profile around
the presumed time of ovulation, which multiplies the number of
blood samples and office visits and in turn results in a more
expensive procedure.
To date, two distinct alternatives to the natural menstrual cycle
have been described for replacement of cryopreserved embryos:
light ovulation induction (Mandelbaum et al, 1987), and
endometrial priming with exogenous oestradiol and progesterone
after suppression of the ovarian function by a gonadotrophin-
releasing hormone agonist (GnRHa) (Schmidt et al., 1989;
Meldrum et al., 1989; de Ziegler and Frydman, 1990). In search
of a simpler method for timing transfers of cryopreserved
embryos, we analysed the practicality and the efficacy of a
different approach. This consisted of priming endometrial
receptivity with oral oestradiol valerate and progesterone without
inducing prior suppression of the ovarian function with a GnRH
agonist. The rationale for this approach was that oestradiol
treatment initiated on cycle day 1 would prevent follicular
recruitment by interfering with the inter-cycle rise in plasma
follicle stimulating hormone (FSH); consequently spontaneous
ovulation would be avoided.
In a preliminary study we looked at the hormonal profile and
endometrial histology at the presumed time of implantation
(de Ziegler et al., 1991). Plasma LH increased to surge levels
in all six women studied but no follicular growth was noticed
and no increase in plasma progesterone was triggered by the LH
surges. Day 20 endometrium specimens showed normal secretory
changes similar to previous findings made when oestradiol and
progesterone cycles were administered to women permanently
deprived of their ovarian function. Encouraged by the results of
1353